Reviews

Overall Total Score
3.7 out of 5
Very good | 4500 reviews

What User likes about Mama Theresa's:
This is a great pizza spot, food was really good and the pizza also great.. Just go on a weekend and expect to do pizza in 20 minutes. I waited 45 minutes for my order, but it was really good.. They will meet some Karens, but the best part is, no one will pay them any mind.. Will be back View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about Mama Theresa's:
I'm here all my life until my last visit. The service does not reflect the prices they charge. The wastewater didn't bring us water after we got our food. Didn't even ask if I wanted a refill on my soda. They charge 4 stars Italian restaurant prices, but it is just a pizzeria. Overall, prices do not reflect the quality of food or service. Very disappointed In which mamma T?s has turned. The owner even ignored me when... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Google
4.2 ★ from 1184 reviews
Elena
07.11.2023 - 07:38

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti, Chicken Primavera, Tartufo Parking...

read more
Frank
07.11.2023 - 07:38

**Service:** Dine-in **Meal type:** Dinner **Price per person:** $30–50

John
07.11.2023 - 07:38

This place has the absolute BEST chicken Parm dinner, chicken marsala dinner, penne Ala vodka, plain slice, marsala slice, Buffalo slice I've ever had. They are...

read more
Jennifer
07.11.2023 - 07:38

The best pesto I've ever had—no cream, just pure basil! The house salads with mozzarella are my all-time favorites too!

andrew
07.11.2023 - 07:38

Absolutely fantastic! I frequently order the eggplant Parm, but last week I decided to try the pecan salad for the first time, and now it's my favorite. I've al...

read more
Top-rated
3.0 ★ from 10 reviews
andrew
31.10.2023 - 17:53

Outstanding! I frequently order the eggplant Parmesan, but for the first time last week, I decided to try the pecan salad. It's now my favorite salad! I've had...

read more
M
31.10.2023 - 17:53

I grabbed a slice of pizza for lunch today, and since I often see a crowd of people coming and going, I thought it couldn't be that bad. However, an hour later,...

read more
Nichole
31.10.2023 - 17:53

When I reached out to the restaurant, they offered two options: I could drive back for another 30 minutes to pick up a corrected order, or I could have my name...

read more
kamal
31.10.2023 - 17:53

Been going here since 1993. Food quality plummeted a few years ago. Small portions and exuberant prices. Not worth it anymore. It’s really a shame because it us...

read more
Em
31.10.2023 - 17:53

Hands down the BEST buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had!! Reheats super well in the air fryer too. I am also in love with their salad pizza. It is super vineg...

read more
Menu
3.2 ★ from 8 reviews

This is a great pizza spot, food was really good and the pizza also great.. Just go on a weekend and expect to do pizza in 20 minutes. I waited 45 minutes for m...

read more

I'm here all my life until my last visit. The service does not reflect the prices they charge. The wastewater didn't bring us water after we got our food. Didn'...

read more

I have been coming here for years, always honest good meals at good prices, you could say that their busy take counters and the number of workers who tend to be...

read more

I was often here for meals and the food is always very good. My last visit was just a quick lunch. The pizza was delicious and the guy at the counter was friend...

read more

When the food arrived, I took just one bite of the pizza and found the prosciutto to taste stale and the truffle oil to be of poor quality. Given the high price...

read more
Tripadvisor
3.9 ★ from 166 reviews
Yelp
3.6 ★ from 425 reviews
Restaurantguru
3.9 ★ from 1847 reviews
Sirved
4.1 ★ from 860 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near New Hyde Park

4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Elmhurst (near New Hyde Park), 83-25 Broadway, Elmhurst, New York, USA, 11373, United States
"The white peach green tea with tapioca was excellent."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Massapequa (near New Hyde Park), 1495 Hicksville Road, Massapequa, United States Of America
"Food is great and customer service is always on point"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: City of New York (near New Hyde Park), 78-14 Roosevelt Ave, Queens, NY 11372, City of New York, United States
"The shakes are normally good, and this was the first juice and panini I had from juice and shake. The cold buster tasted good, and the chicken panini..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Broad Channel (near New Hyde Park), 42-56 196th Street, City Of New York, 11358, United States Of America, Broad Channel
"FANTASTIC FOOD! All the vegan options are delicious! We tried most of them out. The vegan cookies are especially soft. Also, the Mixed Berry Smoothie..."
4.6
Menu
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Open Now
City: Valley Stream (near New Hyde Park), 124 Brooklyn Ave, 11581, Valley Stream, United States
"Once you go into you know you are for a treat! #Veganuary"
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Great Neck Plaza (near New Hyde Park), 71 Middle Neck Rd, 11021, Great Neck Plaza, United States
"Great! I have celiac disease and this restaurant accommodates my dietary needs. Thank you for the delicious meal!"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Garden City (near New Hyde Park), 630 Old Country Rd. Suite LL02 Garden City, NY 11530, 11530-4500, United States
"Food, service atmosphere is always exceptional"
4.6
Menu
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Open Now
City: Queens (near New Hyde Park), La Esquina Del Camaron Mexicano, 80-02 Roosevelt Ave, Jackson Heights, NY 11372, USA, Queens, United States
"Saw this place in youtube so of course we had to try it. We got the coctel mixto (shrimp and octopus). Definitely recommend.Cash only."
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: LOCUST VALLEY (near New Hyde Park), Forest Avenue, 107, Locust Valley Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews, United States Of America, LOCUST VALLEY
"Wonderful evening- good food and great ambiance and service"
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Bethpage (near New Hyde Park), 4246 Hicksville Rd, 11771, Bethpage, United States
"Staff is nice and ice cream is very good"