Goodfella's Pizza Pub - Feedback

I was told that Goodfellas was a must try in the Nekoosa/port Edwards area for pizza when I describe what I really enjoy in a pizza that is a cracker, thin crus...

The food was delicious. It is in an old library. Needs alot of updates. I was happy with food but wait was long. Don't go here if you are short on time.

Wonderful hometown Italian Restaurant with incredible food set in our old historic library. When I give my son free choice of where to get pizza, he always choo...

Completely ridiculous how slow they are. Takes HOURS for any delivery. If you want to eat here order hours before you think you might be hungry. Was told today...

One calzone and a large pizza for the two of us we love taking leftovers home! Piping hot, crispy crust and great flavor. This is our go to place for pizza in t...

Dietary restrictions: So nice to see they had multiple options for gluten free pizza. Everything was delicious! GF and traditional alike! Service: Dine in Meal...

Great service. Pizza was delicious as usual Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Pizza was alright, although the buffalo chicken was lacking the buffalo factor. Breadsticks were in the shape of a stick but that’s about all they had going for...

We have been searching for a great old school pizza joint and have found one in Goodfellas Pizza. The food is homemade and fabulous. Besides pizza, Goodfellas h...

Loved their Rueben Pizza it was amazing!! Bartender was so friendly and their spicy Italian pizza was awesome also!! They have great beer selection too!! We cam...

By far best pizza and calzones in area. Since moving from SE Wisconsin I worried I wouldn?t be able to enjoy good Italian, I was wrong. It?s not as good as a De...

Best place for Italian cuisine. Pizza is outstanding. Waitress's phenomenal. Very personable. We made it our place to go and enjoy every Friday for dinner. Try...

We waited forty-five minutes for our food. When we finally inquired about its status, the waitress took five minutes to respond and let us know that our order h...

Great restaurant! I visited with a friend, and we both loved the food. The waiter was pleasant and welcoming, and the pizza was excellent.

The food was outstanding, and the service was very friendly. My husband absolutely loved the pizza, while I thoroughly enjoyed the calzones—definitely the best...

Great pizzeria. Awesome service! Nice historic building. Has a pub, well established.

I visited this place while on vacation and I must say, the pizza is fantastic! We took advantage of their Monday night pizza deal and it was a great choice. It...

This is top-quality pizza, no questions asked. There’s no need for any qualifiers, even when considering it's in a small town like Beaver Balls Township, Wiscon...

If you’re a fan of Italian cuisine, this is a fantastic place to visit. The staff is friendly, and the restaurant is situated in Nekoosa's historic original lib...