The Branding Iron Supper Club.

The seafood here is terrible. Not fresh at all. After eating the scallops which I had to choke down because they were not fresh I tried to eat my salmon. It to my very disappointment was the worst salmon I've ever had. It was overcooked (I asked for it to be medium rare closer to rare, it was cooked closer to well done) and fishy tasting. It immediately made me feel ill. The waitress was very sweet and felt bad but offered for me to take it home. Now why on earth would I take something home that isn't fresh or even edible. It's not going to get better at home. I asked for it to be removed and they still charged me for half of the salmon and full charge on my scallops. Not to mention it's way overpriced to begin with when some food is bad and can't be eaten you remove the charge END OF STORY! I would never recommend this place.

This is a have to try and I promise you will Not be disappointed. They serve prime rib everyday and it one of my favorites

Overall they score a B+. Old fashion was good but no real selection of garnish, fruit or olives, really? In Wisconsin? Strike. Not Getting my friend the water she ordered at the bar, strike. Couldn't get the attention of the bartender to even try and get it. They were friendly and quick. Orders are place while at the bar, which is common amongst Supper Clubs. Pricing was high but not outrageous. We both ordered Prime Rib. I had the petite as rare as they could. My friend ordered the queen cut medium to rare. Hers was to rare for her, I was jealous cuz mine was more towards the temp she ordered. The meat was delicious! Baked potatoes we screaming hot. Salad bar was SMALL. One cheese spread and pâté several pasta salads, mixed greens lettuce. Overall sufficient. The crackers for the spreads left you wanting, not much variety. Food service was prompt and friendly. Checked back a few times but not bothersome. Ice cream drinks were excellent. The dining room is small, wood panel had funky glitter highlights. It was clean and easy to maneuver. If your looking for nearly a classic experience you can find it here. We enjoyed our meal. Total for two with ice cream drinks was $94 and change. I would come back.

Food always great as is the service and ambiance! Always enjoy interacting with Cheri and the staff. 5 Stars

We went for dinner during the week and had a fantastic meal. Everything was a nicely portioned and cooked well. The atmosphere was classic supper club including a salad bar. Our waitress even left a water carafe on our table so we wouldn't have to ask for refills. My only minor complaint was the salad dressing. We got only a small plastic cup which was a little cheap. We will definitely be coming back.