Kitty Murtaghs - NANTUCKET

#17 - Seafood - NANTUCKET, American, Casual
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Kitty Murtaghs.

Kitty Murtaghs

Kitty Murtaghs
4.3 / 5 (512 reviews)

Menu

The place from NANTUCKET offers 64 different courses and drinks on the menu for an average price of $15.4.

Kitty Murtagh's offers separate lunch and dinner menus showcasing signature dishes like Chip's or Shepherd's pie, chips and curry, beer battered fish, beef stew, bangers and mashed, and Kitty's triple tenderloin. The restaurant is a perfect venue for private parties and also offers Lunch Club and Sunday Brunch specials, along with live music every Friday night. The full bar serves a selection of Irish red ale, Irish whiskeys, draft beer, and wines. Guests can enjoy complimentary Wi-Fi as part of the overall experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Aniya

Images

Kitty Murtaghs Food Kitty Murtaghs Food Kitty Murtaghs Food Kitty Murtaghs Food

Reservation request for Kitty Murtaghs

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 512 reviews

Was Liza Bins at Kitty Murtaghs a mag?
(Post-rest-of-the-meal review) My wife had the short rib stroganoff, and I had the fish and chips, and both dishes were absolutely perfect. When I imagine how fish and chips should taste, this is exactly it. The batter was amazing - crispy, light, and flakey. The short ribs were tender and delicious. The service was very nice, despite the fact that they have been understaffed lately. We didn't have to wait for a table, but there was a bit of a wait for our food. However, it was definitely worth it. We will definitely be returning when we come back to Nantucket!.

alfreda-17
26.08.2021

We enjoyed our late dinner at Kitty’s. in my drinking days, this is exactly the place where I would like to hang around – and I mean that in the best way. it certainly had the feeling of a local place. it is warm and cozy and friendly and I could see sitting in the bar for a few hours watching the game and chatting with the regular. for the food we started with the big brezel with cheese and when they say big they mean big. the bretzel was warm and salty and tasty and the smoked jalapeño cheese sauce was on site. I wish there were more of it. for dinner we had the porterhouse burger, the chickenerquesadilla and a beside salad. everything we ordered was quite simple, but it was really good. we didn't find anything funny – just eating some well cooked – and that's exactly what we did. the service was neighboring and our waiter gave us some great tips about the island. I will definitely return to Kitty’s. it is also important to mention that it is one of the few places on the island that they do not let gasse when looking at the prices on the menu. they are reasonable and they get a great meal!

johnston-tianna
27.07.2022

The food was delicious and the staff was excellent.

hortense53-1
27.07.2022

The service was no longer to serve. the waitress was great. is ice cold and eating was great. they are house blue cheese was best I ever had.

aniya35
27.07.2022

Service was fantastic! sheperd's pie was amazing!

fahey-lori
27.07.2022

Nice pub/bar. the service was great and fast despite the fact that they were busy. I'd come back.

  • Bits & Bobs

    Biggie Pretzel
    Biggie Pretzel
    $11.9
  • Posh Nosh

    Pan Seared Pork Schnitzel
    Pan Seared Pork Schnitzel
    $27.7
  • From Da Yard

    Kitty Da Greek
    Kitty Da Greek
    $13.9
  • Pub Favorites

    Da Famous Irish Fry Up
    Da Famous Irish Fry Up
    $15.9
  • Buttys (Served Until 4Pm)

    Dublin Philly
    Dublin Philly
    $16.8
  • Buttys On Da Grill

    Kitty's Porterhouse Burger
    Kitty's Porterhouse Burger
    $20.8

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.