Arno's - NANTUCKET

Italian, Wine, Pasta
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +17743338121
Reservation
Reservation request for Arno's.

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Arno's from NANTUCKET featuring all 39 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Chef A.J. Black brings a modern twist to Italian dining and organic cuisine at Arno's in Nantucket, Massachusetts. Drawing inspiration from his Sicilian heritage, Chef Black is known for his critically-acclaimed dishes made with the freshest ingredients.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Samanta

Reservation request for Arno's

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 2.9 / 5 from 43 reviews

This new local BYOB spot has quickly become a favorite for those looking for well-crafted, interesting, and beautifully plated food. The staff is warm and friendly, accommodating dietary restrictions with ease. The atmosphere is charming, making it perfect for a casual walk-in or a special night out. While the portions may be small for big eaters, the food is prepared perfectly and presented beautifully. Some diners mentioned that the noise level was slightly high, but overall, the dining experience was excellent. The food received rave reviews, with dishes like couscous, chicken, merguez, lamb, rabbit, cumin chickpeas, and desserts standing out. Overall, this restaurant offers a high level of dining experience that keeps customers coming back.

carolina-pirvu
Carolina 01.11.2017 - 12:15

We wish we owners well They have some work to do Flavors all there but pasta a little al dente as were the fingerling potatoes.

diethelm22
Diethelm 01.11.2017 - 12:15

I feel inclined to write this review even before my food comes outI'm not too excited.

franco-esther
Esther 01.11.2017 - 12:15

Ah, NO!!!! Why would I take my family here after seeing they've tried to redo Aron's from the past! AND then you read the recent Yelp! reviews.

samanta33
Samanta 14.04.2023 - 16:30

I went to Arno's restaurant only to find that it was closed. Completely closed. There was no sign on the door. It was almost completely dark. I had to find another place to eat.

ines-cruickshank
Ines 14.04.2023 - 16:30

I enjoyed the music, it added to the perfect dining experience. The ink paste was especially delicious!

Full Menu

  • Soups, Appetizers And Salads

    Bowl Of Quahog Chowder
    Bowl Of Quahog Chowder
  • Sandwiches

    Grilled Naturally Raised Beef Burger
    Grilled Naturally Raised Beef Burger
  • Dinners

    Fried Or Pan Seared Flounder
    Fried Or Pan Seared Flounder
    Pan-Seared Herb-Crusted Haddock
    Pan-Seared Herb-Crusted Haddock
  • Surf And Turf

    Grass Fed Boneless Prime Rib
    Grass Fed Boneless Prime Rib
    Natural Chicken Breast Marsala
    Natural Chicken Breast Marsala

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.