Spanish Tavern - Mountainside

#8 - Pizza - MOUNTAINSIDE, Spanish, Seafood
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19082322171
Reservation
Reservation request for Spanish Tavern - Mountainside.

Menu

The menu of Spanish Tavern - Mountainside from MOUNTAINSIDE includes 240 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $18.1. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Spanish Tavern seems to be a hit-or-miss restaurant, with a mix of positive and negative reviews. While some diners enjoyed the grilled octopus appetizer, rice side, and chocolate cake, others were disappointed by the mediocre paella and dry aged beef tips. Service also seems to be inconsistent, with some customers praising their server while others felt ignored. Despite the ups and downs, the restaurant appears to be a popular spot for big parties and special occasions. Overall, the food quality, service, and ambiance at Spanish Tavern may vary, so it could be worth a try for those looking for a casual dining experience with a varied menu selection.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: grandeson

Images

Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food Spanish Tavern - Mountainside Food

Reservation request for Spanish Tavern - Mountainside

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 10218 reviews

Was MARS at Spanish Tavern - Mountainside a mag?
The food was delicious and tasty. So far the best paella I've ever tasted. And the dessert that was home made was just perfect...not to sweet not to sour. Excellent. View all feedback.

What jpcdinner dislikes about Spanish Tavern - Mountainside:
We hadn't been to Spanish Tavern in years. We found it okay. The food was fine, a bit on the salty side. The seafood was unevenly cooked. In the same dish, some lobster was perfect other was overcooked and dry. Best things: grilled octopus appetizer, side of rice, chocolate mouse cake. Don't bother with the tres leches cake; somehow it managed to be dry with a soggy bottom (served in a puddle of sweet milk). It seems... View all feedback.

katherine-b
Katherine 20.09.2023 - 17:15

Excellent service. Very accommodating. Food was excellent. Highly recommend. It's on route 22. Try it!

eric-s-2
Eric 20.09.2023 - 17:15

An old coworker of mine used tell me about this place often. I finally had the opportunity to check it out between my kid's basketball games next door. We...

marvin-k
Marvin 20.09.2023 - 17:15

My wife and I stopped in mid-afternoon of Labor Day. We had been here at least a half dozen times in the past and had always enjoyed the food and service....

grandeson
grandeson 21.11.2023 - 00:20

Solid all around. Never bad, but never blows you away. Atmosphere perfect for multi situations. Full bar, attentive staff (though looks like a whole new crew from yesteryears). We go every couple of years and had a Christenings here as well. Worth checking out. Should bring back the grilled calamari vinaigrette appetizer. Though it never was on the menu, a waiter suggested it once and it was the best dish they had. Service: Dine in

hugo-pozo
Hugo 21.11.2023 - 00:20

The customer service at this restaurant is outstanding. The food, service, and atmosphere all receive a perfect 5 rating.

  • Tapas - Appetizers

    Spanish Escargots
    Spanish Escargots
    $6.2
    Shrimp-In-Garlic Tapa
    Shrimp-In-Garlic Tapa
    $6.9
    Spiced Potatoes (Patatas Bravas)
    Spiced Potatoes (Patatas Bravas)
    $4.7
  • Meat & Poultry Entrées

    Slices Of Filet Mignon With Shrimp
    Slices Of Filet Mignon With Shrimp
    $16.4
  • Small Plates

    Crab Smoked Salmon Salad
    Crab Smoked Salmon Salad
    $13.9
  • Seafood

    Day Boat Scallops Spanish-Tavern-Style
    Day Boat Scallops Spanish-Tavern-Style
    $15.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.