Turtle + the Wolf - Montclair

Seafood, Farm To Table, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19737839800
Reservation
Reservation request for Turtle + the Wolf.

Menu

The place from Montclair offers 71 different courses and drinks on the menu at an average price of $17.6.

Mixed reviews of Turtle and The Wolf restaurant in Montclair. While some diners found the food to be delicious and the service to be excellent, others were disappointed with the lack of attention from the staff and the high prices. Some felt the portions were too small for the price, while others praised the unique dishes and friendly service. Overall, opinions on the atmosphere were split, with some feeling it was not worth the prices, while others enjoyed the funky and elegant vibe. The dessert menu received high praise from multiple diners. Despite some negative experiences, others highly recommended the restaurant for its delicious food and excellent service, with one reviewer even having a personal call from the owner to address any concerns. Ultimately, opinions on Turtle and The Wolf seem to vary, with some finding it to be a must-visit spot in Montclair, while others were left feeling disappointed.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Ed

Images

Turtle + the Wolf Food Turtle + the Wolf Food Turtle + the Wolf Drink Turtle + the Wolf Menu Turtle + the Wolf Food Turtle + the Wolf Menu Turtle + the Wolf Food Turtle + the Wolf Food

Reservation request for Turtle + the Wolf

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 4832 reviews

Was DAMIAN ALBERTO MIRANDA MORALES at Turtle + the Wolf a mag?
The food at this restaurant is absolutely outstanding, and you can bring your own drinks (BYOB). Each time we've visited, the waitstaff has provided excellent service. Plus, the prices are very reasonable given the top-notch quality of the food. View all feedback.

What Payton Kessler dislikes about Turtle + the Wolf:
Just didn't particularly like the atmosphere . It doesn't warrant the prices though the chicken was very good. Don't feel it's nice enough for a get together unless it's your local restaurant. The waiters and waitresses were overly casual in dress which we thought was a bit odd at those prices. View all feedback.

logan-436
Logan 20.10.2018 - 08:28

This was our third time in this excellent neighboring restaurant, and we always say how amazing it is. the food and service equally excellent. I wish there were more than one fish option, but otherwise there are nothing but full compliments for the creative menu with locally produced food. the appetizers, like red thunfisch crudo, bruschetta and bark briskettar are delicious from the charts. we have already booked another reservation and cannot wait to go back!

monserrate-4
Monserrate 17.11.2021 - 16:53

My favorite restaurant montclair! I love the menu and the mood.

frieda-40
Frieda 20.10.2018 - 16:53

We made the fried chicken dinner and it was soouuuo stinking dee-licious. the sides were also great. eating is always delicious, but a special scream from the amazing staff. kind, friendly, always a pleasure!

ed-chang
Ed 24.11.2023 - 14:53

If you're looking for a fantastic dinner experience, I highly recommend visiting this restaurant. The average cost per person is usually between $50 and $100. Some of their must-try dishes include the Pecorino Arancini, Lo's Famous Fried Chicken, and their delicious Brioche Donuts. These dishes are bound to delight your taste buds and have you coming back for more. Be sure to check out this dining spot!

logan-schurig
Logan 24.11.2023 - 14:53

The atmosphere at this restaurant was wonderful. The interior decor was both charming and inviting, creating a cozy and warm ambiance. The lighting was perfect, the music was enjoyable, and the overall vibe was relaxed and pleasant. It was an ideal setting for a lovely meal with friends or family.

  • Dinner

    Fresh Shucked Oyster 1/2 Dz
    Fresh Shucked Oyster 1/2 Dz
    $21.0
    Hand-Cut Pappardelle Pork Sugo
    Hand-Cut Pappardelle Pork Sugo
    $25.0
    Pecorino Arancini
    Pecorino Arancini
    $7.0
    Kabocha Squash Agnolotti
    Kabocha Squash Agnolotti
    $23.0
    Maple Pot De Creme
    Maple Pot De Creme
    $9.0
  • Entrées

    Roasted Spanish Octopus
    Roasted Spanish Octopus
    $29.0

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.