Reviews
What Lia A doesn't like about Sammys:
My friends from New York and I arrived at Sammy's around 2 PM on a Sunday, absolutely starving. We picked up the menus by the door and started to look through our options. We were... View all feedback. What User likes about Sammys:
Without a doubt, this is the best restaurant in town. The food here is exceptional. If you're looking for an authentic Montauk experience, you must visit Sammy's. Sammy is a local, as is the rest of the staff. His mother was the kindergarten teacher at Montauk School for many years (she taught me too!). It's truly a hidden gem in the city where the locals go to eat. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I know it’s not season but when have people coming over on November and you are open just be happy to have someone in your restaurant since nobody is around !!!...
read moreI know it’s not season but when have people coming over on November and you are open just be happy to have someone in your restaurant since nobody is around !!!...
read moreLove Sammy's! Great food, reasonable prices, great atmosphere... And kids love the big fish tank! Always great being by the Dock.
Hey, it's Ginger from Gilligan's Island. Our hostess name is Ginger and she looks like Ginger from Gilligan's Island. She is beautiful. We had a great time and...
read moreI’ve been coming to Sammy’s every summer for a few years now and it is such a lovely experience every time. Highly recommend. One of the best impossible burgers...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreStop for a quick bite and really enjoyed the place. Good food, very friendly staff, comfortable place with reasonable prices. Would recommend.
Ice cream is great and you can get hot coffee too, bonus!
Without a doubt, this is the best restaurant in town. The food here is exceptional. If you're looking for an authentic Montauk experience, you must visit Sammy'...
read moreWe enjoyed a delightful Oktoberfest dinner at Sammy's tonight. The food is consistently excellent, and both the Sauerbraten and Wienerschnitzel were outstanding...
read moreWe had an incredible meal featuring tender lamb with polenta, lamb ragu, and a side of asparagus. The lamb was so tender it practically fell off the bone, and t...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreMy friends from New York and I arrived at Sammy's around 2 PM on a Sunday, absolutely starving. We picked up the menus by the door and started to look through o...
read moreThe lobster roll was loaded with lobster! We enjoyed sitting outside with a lovely view of the harbor. The service was very friendly. I would definitely return!
I absolutely LOVE the lobster burger here! I've dined at this restaurant many times, and during my first visit, I was astonished to discover that lobster could...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more