Hooked - MONTAUK
Hooked
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Hooked in MONTAUK. At the moment, there are 27 dishes and drinks on the menu.
Hooked in Montauk, NY is a popular American restaurant with an average rating of 4.6 stars. Visit us today from 12:00 PM to 7:00 PM and enjoy our delicious and healthy menu options. Don't forget to call ahead to reserve your table at (631) 668-2111. If you enjoy our menu, be sure to check out Goldberg's Bagels and Wasabi Beach Restaurant Sushi Bar for similar options. Share your experience with us by leaving a review!.
Images
Feedback
Nestled in a scenic spot with inviting indoor and pet-friendly outdoor seating, this restaurant offers generous portions and standout dishes like exceptional calamari and perfectly cooked Mahi. The lobster roll, priced at $32, features a good lobster-to-mayo balance but is let down by its bun, which some find underwhelming for the cost. While the flavors can be inconsistent—with some dishes described as average—the clam chowder and lobster bisque receive high praise. The highlight remains the warm, knowledgeable staff and the picturesque views, making it a worthwhile stop for a casual yet memorable dining experience in the Hamptons.
Hooked?s lobster roll is stuffed with lobster, has minimal mayo, and is just plain delicious. Definitely my favorite lobster roll in the Montauk area. Great fast casual joint with efficient service and plenty of outdoor seating. They also have avariety of alcoholic beverages available to enjoy with your meal. I?m looking forward to trying more of the menu during my nextvisit.
Me and my girlfriend stopped by from our stay in the Hamptons and it was one of the greatest decisions we've ever made. Prices are fair and the food is spectacular! The food is definitely worth trying and totally worth it, would definitely come back inthe future!
The portion sizes were quite generous, and the customer service at the counter was outstanding. However, the food was just average. We were expecting a more remarkable experience based on other reviews, but it didn't quite live up to our expectations. I would still recommend trying it out, as each menu item offers something unique (we only sampled the shrimp boat with fries). There was plenty of outdoor seating, which was also pet-friendly since we dined outside. I must highlight that the counter staff were exceptionally knowledgeable and truly fantastic!
The atmosphere inside the restaurant was enjoyable, and at first, I found the price of the lobster roll ($32) to be fair. However, I was expecting more and ended up feeling somewhat disappointed. The balance of lobster to mayo was perfect, but the hot dog bun did not impress me. Considering the clientele and the price, I expected a more refined presentation that would enhance the overall dining experience.
Full Menu
Chowders & Soups
Kick'n Crab & Corn ChowderAppetizers
Steamed Mussels In White Wine & GarlicSalads
Hooked House Salad
Beet & Baby Arugula SaladStarters
Whole Local Steamed Lobster
Grilled Tuna, Swordfish Or Mahi Mahi
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.1 / 5 (6681 reviews)#16 Seafood in MONTAUKScarpetta Beach
Old Montauk Highway 290, 11954-5048 MONTAUK, US
"Fun and cool vibes had a great time will be back soon"
★ 4.0 / 5 (130 reviews)#23 Seafood in MONTAUK MediterraneanArbor
Fort Pond Road 240, 11954-5249 MONTAUK, US
"Delightful, fun and exceptionally delicious."
★ 4.1 / 5 (1644 reviews)#19 Seafood in MONTAUK FrenchSwallow East
West Lake Drive 474, 11954 MONTAUK, US
"The food was absolutely awful. The chef had a terrible attitude."