Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Sammys:
Without a doubt, this is the best restaurant in town. The food here is exceptional. If you're looking for an authentic Montauk experience, you must visit Sammy's. Sammy is a local, as is the rest of the staff. His mother was the kindergarten teacher at Montauk School for many years (she taught me too!). It's truly a hidden gem in the city where the locals go to eat. View all feedback.
What Lia A doesn't like about Sammys:
My friends from New York and I arrived at Sammy's around 2 PM on a Sunday, absolutely starving. We picked up the menus by the door and started to look through our options. We were... View all feedback.
I know it’s not season but when have people coming over on November and you are open just be happy to have someone in your restaurant since nobody is around !!!You welcome us with a face on and complaining about our bottle water instead asking us what we wanted. !!!!LikeBye ?
I know it’s not season but when have people coming over on November and you are open just be happy to have someone in your restaurant since nobody is around !!!You welcome us with a face on and complaining about our bottle water instead asking us what we wanted. !!!!LikeBye ?
Love Sammy's! Great food, reasonable prices, great atmosphere... And kids love the big fish tank! Always great being by the Dock.
Hey, it's Ginger from Gilligan's Island. Our hostess name is Ginger and she looks like Ginger from Gilligan's Island. She is beautiful. We had a great time and the food was so delicious. I can't believe I finished my whole plate, it was that good. Hats off to the Chef de Cuisine. The place was recommended by someone who was fishing near The Lighthouse.
I’ve been coming to Sammy’s every summer for a few years now and it is such a lovely experience every time. Highly recommend. One of the best impossible burgers I’ve ever had!! Vegetarian options: Your only options as a vegetarian are a few salads and an impossible burger. However, they make these options super well and I would highly recommend.
Full Menu
Download Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
