Tenuta's - Milwaukee

Italian, Pizza, Wine
Reservation
Reservation request for Tenuta's.

Tenuta's

Tenuta's
4.2 / 5 (2299 reviews)

Description

The article describes a restaurant in the Bayview neighborhood of Milwaukee that offers excellent service and delicious food. The reviewers highlight the homemade sauces, fresh pizza with generous toppings, and extensive wine selection. They also mention the cozy atmosphere and recommend it for date nights or special occasions. Although some reviewers had mixed experiences with portion sizes or waiting times, overall, the restaurant seems to be a popular choice for Italian cuisine enthusiasts in the area.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Emilie

Reservation request for Tenuta's

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 2299 reviews
wschluter-1
26.02.2025

There is a very pungent smell of cigarette right when you walk in, it was very unpleasant. Our host was very kind and got our table ready even though we didn?t have a reservation. I do recommend making one ahead of time because it seemed to get very busywhile we waited for our food, which was a very long wait. It took nearly an hour for our food to arrive, and we got there beforethe rush started. Our server was professional and friendly, she checked up on us often. My family said they wouldn?t come backbecause the food was okay but not great. I, however, would come back for the Shrimp Scampi, aside from the strong garlic flavorand garlic pieces, I actually enjoyed this dish. We also got a tiramisu for desert and were extremely disappointed. It was verydry and thick, and lacked coffee flavor, I do not recommend the tiramisu here. Over all had an okay experience at Tenuta?s.

agutkowski-4
26.02.2025

Every single dish (6 different pastas and 2 appetizers) was phenomenal! If I didn't live in California I'd be there weekly! So glad my brother lives in wauwatosa and I can come when I visit. This is my second time going and it still was delicious withzero disappointment? Our server was ok, nothing above and beyond. Kinda felt like she was ready to go home.

ufahey-2
26.02.2025

I visited this charming local restaurant for the first time. It was quite busy, and they were short on staff, so we ended up sitting at the bar. The service was good, and both the wine and pasta were delicious.

walton04
26.02.2025

I always enjoy dining here. The pasta is consistently delicious. I recently took my mother-in-law out for dinner with my wife, and the staff were incredibly friendly. They were attentive and gave excellent recommendations. Without a doubt, this is one of the best places for pasta in Milwaukee.

laura-soto-5
26.02.2025

I visited Tenuta’s for Father’s Day dinner and was impressed by the friendly staff who gave excellent recommendations on the pasta dishes. Their guidance was much appreciated, as everything sounded tempting—and it really was! The traditional Carbonara was outstanding (though quite rich), the short rib (Manzo) was fantastic, and the mushroom ravioli (Funghi) left a lasting impression that will have us coming back for more. The smallest pizza size was surprisingly generous, with a puffier virgin-style crust that was absolutely delicious. If you haven’t been to Tenuta’s yet, be sure to visit for your next special meal!

FAQ

The restaurant offers free WiFi for its customers.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.