Peter Sciortino's Bakery - Milwaukee

Italian, Bakeries, Pizza
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Peter Sciortino's Bakery

Peter Sciortino's Bakery
4.2 / 5 (1162 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Peter Sciortino's Bakery from Milwaukee includes 16 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $11.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Sciortino's is a delightful Italian bakery that offers a wide variety of delicious treats. While some customers have had mixed experiences with the cupcakes being a bit dry, the cookie assortment was a standout for many. The customer service has been described as courteous and kind, with pre-ordering being a convenient option for many. The cakes are highly recommended, being described as far superior to grocery store options. The bakery itself has a welcoming atmosphere, with friendly employees and reasonable prices for their quality goods. Overall, Sciortino's is known for their fantastic Italian bread, cookies, and cakes, making it a classic and must-visit bakery in the area.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Marizona

Images

Peter Sciortino's Bakery Food Peter Sciortino's Bakery Food Peter Sciortino's Bakery Food Peter Sciortino's Bakery Food Peter Sciortino's Bakery Food Peter Sciortino's Bakery Menu Peter Sciortino's Bakery Outside Peter Sciortino's Bakery Outside

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 1162 reviews

Was Mona Lisa Battaglia at Peter Sciortino's Bakery a mag?
Customer service was courteous and kind. I ordered ahead which I love to do so pickup is easy and you get exactly what you are looking for. Expensive, but nice for a treat a few times a year. Desserts were very good. We purchased chocolate tutus, coconut cookies dipped in chocolate, eclairs, cannoli, and sfogliatelle. Dee-lish! View all feedback.

What Santina Hoeger dislikes about Peter Sciortino's Bakery:
Stumbled upon this place when I was exploring the neighborhood. Everything looks delicious. I got an assortment of cookies (9.95) as well as the banana split cupcake, about 5 bucks. I was a little disappointed because although it had a good flavor, it was dry. I read other reviews about this issue, as well as the response from the owners. Seems like there is no resolve about this. The creme topping that was used had... View all feedback.

fauer-rabbit8778
24.11.2017

Yum!!!! This has been a classic in my family since before I was born.

winifred-mills
24.11.2017

I stopped in because of a high recommendation from a co-workerBoy am I glad I did! They have the most delightful little Italian cookies.

rdeckow
24.11.2017

My family and I were here yesterday for the Brady Street Pet Parade I found they had a wide variety of bakery items along with deli.

marizona
20.07.2023

I come here just for the nutella croissant! love this place

mona-44
20.07.2023

Customer service was courteous and kind. I ordered ahead which I love to do so pickup is easy and you get exactly what you are looking for. Expensive, but nice for a treat a few times a year. Desserts were very good. We purchased chocolate tutus, coconut cookies dipped in chocolate, eclairs, cannoli, and sfogliatelle. Dee-lish!

  • Biscuits

    Pecan Finger Per Pound
    Pecan Finger Per Pound

    Ground pecans throughout a faint taste of orange. Rolled in powder sugar.

    $10.7
    Mexican Wedding Cake Per Pound
    Mexican Wedding Cake Per Pound

    A very buttery white cookie rolled in powder sugar. Contains no nuts / fruit.

    $10.7
  • Dessert

  • Wrap

  • This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.