Reviews
What Monica Walla doesn't like about Main Street Italian Eatery:
Hearty homemade pastas. Good portions. Which is suprisingly hard to find in Milton for take-out. I especially enjoy their Gnocchi w/ Meat & Cheese.I noticed right away there was a sense of community and family with customers. I witnessed multiple people being greeted by their first names on entry. And genuinely familiar banter, while food was being prepared.Granted, most of these customers had noticable Italian accen... View all feedback. What Joyce B likes about Main Street Italian Eatery:
Stopped to pick up a chicken parm sandwich Friday evening, not realizing it was cash only. Super friendly staff said no problem, take the sandwich and come back another time to pay! WOW this is the spirit I have grown to love since moving to Milton 40+ years ago and is, sadly, becoming less prevalent as time goes by. Sandwich was awesome and made better by the kindness of this establishment. I will definitely go back... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Is it abnormal to get a grilled cheese at an Italian restaurant? I mean, I was hesitant at first but thank Christ I did. The Prosciutto Cotto Grilled
When we walked in it looked very deli style. It was an hour before closing so most of the food had been taken out of the display area. The owner told us our opt...
read moreFresh and homemade food. The staff are very welcoming. chicken parm on a fresh roll is heavenly. Pizza is delicious. You will be glad you stopped there to eat.
Chicken parm sandwich is hands down the best! The owner is so sweet and friendly. It's been around for years for a good reason ????
Fantastic veal! I had it a friends one night (they ordered a tray of veal smothered in tomato sauce) and was really impressed. I have now ordered the veal a few...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI go to the Main Street Italian Eatery to get great take out food. They make an authentic Italian sandwich to go. We also get a lot of food for get-togethers. T...
read moreDelicious, worth every nickle (bring cash). The vegetables were a little heavy on the oil but still yummy.
Stopped to pick up a chicken parm sandwich Friday evening, not realizing it was cash only. Super friendly staff said no problem, take the sandwich and come back...
read moreI felt like some Italian food and thought I would give this place a try based on the reviews. It was not what I was expecting. I would not really classify this...
read moreI have visited The Eatery in the past for their excellent coffee. Last week, I inquired with Rocco if they had lasagna available. He mentioned that they were ma...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more