Cala's Pizza - Mentor

#9 - Pizza - Mentor, Lunch, Cheese

Cala's Pizza

Cala's Pizza
4.2 / 5 (275 reviews)

Description

This neighborhood pizzeria consistently delivers classic, well-balanced pizzas with flavorful, homemade-tasting sauce, generous cheese, and a satisfying crust. Standout sides include garlicky cheesy bread, wings, and hearty appetizers, all presented attractively. Service is fast and personable—staff and owner often accommodate curbside or car pick-up—making it a go-to for families and regulars. Quality is reliable, though some pies can be a bit oily and specialty toppings occasionally light. Ideal for casual dinners, takeout, and weekly pizza nights.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Hipolito

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 275 reviews
hipolito-king
17.04.2023

I order from the Mentor site once a week, and the food is fantastic! I typically get one pizza and an appetizer, and everything I've tried so far has been excellent. I highly recommend this place. The customer service is also commendable, especially from the manager, Ralph, who is always in a good mood and engages in great conversations. I give them a full 5-star rating!

madeline59
17.04.2023

On March 14, 2022, I tried the paprika and roasted paprika pizza. Unfortunately, the toppings were a bit sparse. However, the crust had a great flavor and texture. The sauce tasted homemade rather than from a can, which was a pleasant surprise. The cheese was plentiful and flavorful, allowing it to really shine. Additionally, the cheese bread was generously coated with garlic butter and was wonderfully cheesy.

weissnat-lucinda
17.04.2023

I have ordered from your restaurant countless times over the last year and a half that I’ve been in the area. Outside of being completely impressed by the service that I was given and the quality of food I always recommend you guys to all my friends and family whenever they need pizza or even wings or even a salad. I hope you continue to keep growing And maintaining your quality through growth.

isabella-fritz
17.04.2023

Pleasantly surprised! First time ordering tonight, was ready in 20 mints. Ordered cheese bread, mangia bread, great pizza, Margarita pizza, and pepperoni. All were delicious. A tad on the oily side, but that's what makes good pizza sometimes : Kids loved it!

corwin-enid
17.04.2023

Phenomenal presentation. I ordered a large bbq chicken and it was outstanding. The cheesy bread is abundant and the the wings are exceptional. They def give rascal house a run for there money. . Wow wow

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.