Pookaberry Cafe - Full Menu

I absolutely adore this place! It's exactly what Mattituck needed. The food is fantastic, and the interior is beautiful! Plus, the owners are incredibly friendl... read more I absolutely adore this place! It's exactly what Mattituck needed. The food is fantastic, and the interior is beautiful! Plus, the owners are incredibly friendly and have a great sense of humor!

I was excited to have a new restaurant in town, but my experience there was disappointing. I ordered fish and chips to share with a friend, but was charged for... read more I was excited to have a new restaurant in town, but my experience there was disappointing. I ordered fish and chips to share with a friend, but was charged for two meals plus an extra order of fries. What we received was definitely just one portion, and a small one at that. When I asked for tartar sauce, they didn’t have any, and when I requested vinegar, I was given balsamic instead. It seems like they could benefit from learning more about this classic English dish. Although the waiter corrected the bill, he did so with quite a bit of attitude. The dining room was very dark and had flashing strobe lights, which may pose a risk for those susceptible to seizures. Unfortunately, I doubt I'll be returning.