Pookaberry Cafe - Mattituck

#37 - Pizza - Mattituck, Food, Themed Cafe
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Pookaberry Cafe

Pookaberry Cafe
4.3 / 5 (5 reviews)

Menu

On this webpage, you will find the complete menu of Pookaberry Cafe from Mattituck. Currently, there are 13 menus and drinks available.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Carol

Images

Pookaberry Cafe Food Pookaberry Cafe Food Pookaberry Cafe Logo Pookaberry Cafe Logo Pookaberry Cafe Menu Pookaberry Cafe Inside Pookaberry Cafe Inside Pookaberry Cafe Inside

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 5 reviews

Was Alexa Velez at Pookaberry Cafe a mag?
I absolutely adore this place! It's exactly what Mattituck needed. The food is fantastic, and the interior is beautiful! Plus, the owners are incredibly friendly and have a great sense of humor! View all feedback.

What Carol Sullivan dislikes about Pookaberry Cafe:
I was excited to have a new restaurant in town, but my experience there was disappointing. I ordered fish and chips to share with a friend, but was charged for two meals plus an extra order of fries. What we received was definitely just one portion, and a small one at that. When I asked for tartar sauce, they didn’t have any, and when I requested vinegar, I was given balsamic instead. It seems like they could benefit... View all feedback.

michael-vangi-1
15.05.2024

Pop art meets Philippines eats. The islands best Philippino delicacies I have ever eaten. The atmosphere is awesome with famous work all over the place inside and outside. I noticed they were using local farmed produce, meats, and seafood. If you like pork I must recommend the SISIG it is so delicious!!Parking: The train stop is directly across the street from the place with free municipal parking.Kid-friendliness: Very cool for kids.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a big ramp for wheelchairs.

frank-t-vine7
15.05.2024

Cool little cafe next door to Breeze Hill Farm. You have to walk thru BHF, exit the backdoor and walk to the building next door. The entrance is in the back. Wife runs the cafe, husband is an artist, MarcoArt and his artwork decorates the cafe. He also sells his artwork in a truck by the parking lot. They have a small menu including sandwiches, baked goods, coffee and tea. I had a cappuccino to go with my cider donuts from BHF. They don't mind if you bring in food from next door. They gave us a Portuguese custard on the house. It was so good, I'm going back for another one next week. We also picked up a scone for breakfast tomorrow. There's some crafts for sale. One of the few small shops open during the winter in this area.

andrea-urist
15.05.2024

The restaurant was still in the process of setting up, but the owners were incredibly welcoming and friendly. They quickly arranged a table for my mom and me. We decided to share the Bang Bang shrimp, which was both delicious and full of flavor. My mom was in the mood for pasta, and the chef recommended a cilantro pasta with grilled chicken, which was reminiscent of cilantro pesto—so tasty! However, she thought the chicken could have used a bit more spice. I ordered beef served over yellow rice, and it was simply delicious and packed with flavor. I would love to know their marinade recipe! Beyond the great food, the whole experience felt special and unique. We were treated like family, and we will definitely return! Mattituck could use more diverse dining options. Although I’ve never tried Filipino cuisine before, I found it to be very enjoyable and satisfying!

carol-sullivan-cat50
15.05.2024

I was excited to have a new restaurant in town, but my experience there was disappointing. I ordered fish and chips to share with a friend, but was charged for two meals plus an extra order of fries. What we received was definitely just one portion, and a small one at that. When I asked for tartar sauce, they didn’t have any, and when I requested vinegar, I was given balsamic instead. It seems like they could benefit from learning more about this classic English dish. Although the waiter corrected the bill, he did so with quite a bit of attitude. The dining room was very dark and had flashing strobe lights, which may pose a risk for those susceptible to seizures. Unfortunately, I doubt I'll be returning.

alexa-velez-bank57
15.05.2024

I absolutely adore this place! It's exactly what Mattituck needed. The food is fantastic, and the interior is beautiful! Plus, the owners are incredibly friendly and have a great sense of humor!

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.