Prisco's Gourmet - Mastic

Salads, Gourmet, Grocery
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Prisco's Gourmet

Prisco's Gourmet
3.6 / 5 (913 reviews)

Description

Priscos restaurant faces mixed reviews, highlighting significant inconsistencies in food quality and customer service. Many patrons express disappointment over overpriced and poorly executed dishes, such as the corned beef hash and pastrami sandwich, often describing them as lacking flavor and balance. Customer service appears to be another sore spot, with reports of unprofessional behavior from staff and careless mistakes with orders. However, there are positive notes, particularly regarding certain items like paninis and steak salad, which receive acclaim for their taste and value. Ultimately, while some diners appreciate specific menu items, many others are unlikely to return.

Last update: 17.04.2026 from: Aaditya

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 913 reviews
aaditya-katwal
14.06.2025

I used to order from here ALOT! Today I legit got a RAW brownie delivered to me...come on man! Whoever did that shame on you!

dwalker-horse2706
14.06.2025

I just went here for the first time and ordered two chicken salad heros brought to a friend's for lunch. I was EMBARRASSED by the fact that there was little to NO chicken salad on it ! I am talking like spreading butter on a slice of toast thin ?!!! Ihave never complained about a sandwich before..... but I just spent $20 on lettuce , bacon bread. O_o

devonte10
14.06.2025

I drive past several deli?s almost every morning just to get to Priso?s deli who has the best priced egg sandwich in Suffolk and the sandwich is amazing the price is 5.75 not like blazing bagels nine dollars for a simple egg sandwich

davis-angelita
14.06.2025

Top notch egg sandwiches and great service. Thanks.

j-l-lawyer96
29.12.2023

I love having breakfast from this place! They have a great selection, and the owner is really friendly. I appreciate that they make your coffee fresh! My daughter loves their pink lemonade. The loaded home fries are incredibly tasty! Although I usually go there for breakfast, I often see their hero and panini platters that look absolutely delicious. I'm considering getting my next deli catering order from here because everything looks so tempting! I definitely recommend checking it out.

FAQ

There is a TV / screen on-site where sporting events are broadcast.

The restaurant and its rooms are wheelchair accessible and thus usable with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

The place also accepts credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.