Mama Lisa - Mastic

Pizza, Italian, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Mama Lisa.

Mama Lisa

Mama Lisa
4.2 / 5 (14488 reviews)

Description

Mama Lisa's Restaurant offers a varied dining experience, with some mixed reviews. Some customers found the dishes underwhelming and lacking flavor, particularly the pasta dishes. Others, however, praised the Veal Franchise and roles as favorites. The friendly and attentive staff was a highlight for many, contributing to an overall positive atmosphere. The restaurant offers a wide range of gluten-free options, which were enjoyed by many patrons. Despite some inconsistency in food quality, the warm welcome and professional service at Mama Lisa's make it a recommended spot for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

Last update: 08.07.2026 from: erin

Reservation request for Mama Lisa

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 14488 reviews
erin-sheehan-1
16.02.2025

Guys I gotta give you average. Order chicken marsal could definitely 100% make it better myself at my house. Not enough flavor needs more wine needs more something I had to go home and tweak it to eat it gods honest truth. The prices you’re chargingmake sure your flavors are spot on.

victoria-kyle-elmore
16.02.2025

This restaurant is usually always good. A go to for our family for everything down to big birthday parties but lately the food has been just okay. Their customer service is great but the food has been coming out so sloppily made. It’s getting worseevery time, I figured I’d order early and I’d get a better result but I just got my delivery at 4:00pm and it looks superrushed. $85 dollar order and everything looks like they just didn’t care how it was sent out to someone’s home. It sucksbecause there aren’t many good Italian restaurants out here. I think this will be my last order..

rachel-s-squirrel897
16.02.2025

I ordered the Penne a la Vodka for delivery from this restaurant and was really disappointed. Based on the rave reviews, I expected it to be delicious, but the sauce was bland and lacked any real flavor. Although the chicken was well-cooked, it too was pretty tasteless. I wish I had some cheese or salt on the side to enhance the dish, but it was so unappetizing that I couldn't even finish it. This might have just been a bad night for the restaurant, but I'm unlikely to give it another try.

julie-c-pilot4495
16.02.2025

I just had to stop by again to stock up on the absolute best pizza, chicken rolls, and spinach pinwheels. I highly recommend this place! A special thanks to the owner for taking the time to respond to my message. I plan on coming back and loading up on as many items as I can. This five-star establishment truly deserves rave reviews! I might even need a moving truck to bring it all home. There’s nothing quite like enjoying a delicious New York pizza. Highly recommended for their fantastic selection of food, pizza, and desserts. The pizza is simply delicious!

shimaine-s-1
16.02.2025

This is one of the most overrated restaurants on the island. I find that there's always a 50/50 chance of enjoying my meal, but it’s still a decent and affordable option. A tip: if you’re ordering takeout, pizza is a safer choice than pasta, as they tend to drown the pasta in sauce and cheese. If you’re thinking, "That sounds great to me," trust me—it can overwhelm the dish and ruin the overall experience.

FAQ

The restaurant offers free WLAN for its guests.

You can also enjoy gluten-free meals at the restaurant.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.