The Pump House - Lithopolis

Pizza, Sandwiches, Meat

The Pump House

★ 4.1 / 5 (337 reviews)

**Pump House: A Culinary Journey with Hits and Misses** Pump House has garnered mixed reviews since shifting its focus to wings, with some guests praising its welcoming service and comforting atmosphere, while others express disappointment over the food quality. Though the pizza remains a highlight for some, opinions vary on its consistency. Many fondly recall previous favorites but lament declines in service efficiency and meal presentation. However, a portion of patrons appreciate the diverse beer selection and recommend dishes such as the MooBBQ burger and traditional bone-in wings. Overall, while the experience can be hit-or-miss, loyal fans remain hopeful for improvements.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: James

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 337 reviews

Was Cathie Pardy at The Pump House a mag?
A must place to eat! The food,is amazing. We had,pizza,subs,and wings..the best anywhere..my nephews loved the food,and the atmosphere, nicely decorated and love the plants.. so comfy and relaxing for family to enjoy great food and awesome people taking care of you. Such an upgrade! Great for us locals,and anyone wanting a new place to try,this place will not disappoint! Worth the trip. Food: 5 View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about The Pump House:
"Rustic" is a generous description. The service remains the best aspect of the restaurant, but ever since they transitioned to a wing-focused menu, I'm uncertain about the quality of the food. They still serve pizza, which was a highlight for me when I went to the one in Columbus, but it has changed and now it just doesn't feel the same. It's still good, but it used to be great.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

It's just average. Nothing special, really. The pizza is quite bland.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Rustic" is a generous description. The service remains the best aspect of the restaurant, but ever since they transitioned to a wing-focused menu, I'm uncertain about the quality of the food. They still serve pizza, which was a highlight for me when I went to the one in Columbus, but it has changed and now it just doesn't feel the same. It's still good, but it used to be great.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The best lilbarian I have visited in the time and has really good food. the bartenders are always very nice.