Scream Shack - Lander

Coffee, Ice Cream, Coffee
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Scream Shack

Scream Shack
4.0 / 5 (192 reviews)

Description

Charming, family-favorite ice cream shop in Lander serves homemade, inventive flavors—lemon meringue and chokecherry shakes garner praise—at generous portions and fair prices. Menu includes shakes, sundaes, cones and non-dairy sherbet; portions often overwhelm. Service is usually friendly, perfect for late-night indulgences, but crowds, occasional long waits and uneven staff behavior have been reported. Seasonal hours and inconsistent opening times frustrate some visitors. Small, busy space with limited visibility of tubs; still a must-visit for dessert lovers seeking bold, homemade flavors.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Adam

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 192 reviews
adam-dutko-2
05.01.2024

The ice cream was excellent, but the service left much to be desired. It felt like tourists took priority over the locals, which was disappointing since this is my home. Unfortunately, I had a negative experience due to the rudeness of both the staff and some tourists, and I ended up not getting anything.

adam-dutko-3
05.01.2024

The ice cream here is excellent and the portions are huge! They offer a wide variety of delicious flavors, and the service is very friendly!

adam-dutko-1
05.01.2024

This charming little ice cream shop is fantastic. I would even say that the value for your money is exceptional. Four of us opted for small sizes, and we were each overwhelmed with the generous portions—none of us could finish our servings! I highly recommend it to family and friends.

gerda53-1
05.01.2024

The lemon meringue ice cream was absolutely amazing. Portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. I’m really looking forward to returning and trying more flavors. EDIT: Returned after a long drive since your hours indicated you were open, but it was 2:30 PM on a Thursday and the place was closed! I called, and Gannet Place answered saying you open at 5. What are your actual hours? Are you closing after Labor Day?

xkuhlman-store385
09.05.2023

So happy that Scream is open again for the season! Absolutely the best place I was in condition for a Chokecherry shake. We tend to have them too often, sometimes as often as once a week.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.