Castaways - Lancaster

#2 - Fast Food - Lancaster, Pizza, American

Castaways

Castaways
4.3 / 5 (969 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 4 courses and drinks can be found here on the menu of Castaways from Lancaster.

Dining at this restaurant is truly hit or miss, as evidenced by the wide range of reviews from disappointed customers to raving fans. Some complained of soggy pizza crusts and lackluster dishes, while others praised the delicious steaks and relaxed atmosphere. The service also seemed to be a point of contention, with some guests experiencing rudeness and slow service, while others were impressed by the friendly and quick service they received. Overall, it appears that this restaurant's success may depend on who's working that day and what dishes are ordered.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Julie

Images

Castaways Food Castaways Food Castaways Drink Castaways Outside Castaways Food Castaways Food Castaways Food

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 969 reviews

Was Anonym at Castaways a mag?
My mom grew up here in the 70s. I didn't have high hopes when she brought me. I was a jabroni. The pizza was delicious!! It was very calm and peaceful inside and everyone was nice to me. If you like homestyle Americana, you will not be disappointed. Very tasty, very relaxed, can't wait to come back to OH! View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Castaways:
My husband and I were the first customers of the evening. We were seated at a table and ordered drinks. When our waitress came in back to take our dinner order, we asked if the blaring music could be turned down. She checked with the owner who said they could not. We asked if they could turn it off and I once again were told no. We moved to another table. We are a retired couple who were expecting a nice evening. Res... View all feedback.

ohaag
02.09.2022

My man and I were the first customers of the evening. we sat on a table and ordered drinks. When our waitress came back to take over our food order, we asked if the blowing music could be switched off. She checked with the owner who said they couldn't. we asked if they could turn it off and I said no again. we moved to another table. we are a retired couple who expected a nice evening. the toilets are dirty. foodstraight from the freezer to the frit. will not be back.

lloyd-dach
02.09.2022

Love the hired. Eating is always fantastic and this is never long when there is even one.

schulist-kip
02.09.2022

We had two waitresses. one was very nice, the other who took our order was very short with us and rude. Yes, they were busy, but no reason to be rude. my man and I ordered steaks. neither was boiled right and had no taste, he ordered a side of mushrooms, they were literally a can of cut mushrooms in a cup dumped. ew. we have spent 75 dollars and both have starving. very disappointed to say the least.

julie-rock-store26
17.02.2026

My husband and I were the first customers of the evening. We were seated at a table and ordered drinks. When our waitress came in back to take our dinner order, we asked if the blaring music could be turned down. She checked with the owner who said they could not. We asked if they could turn it off and I once again were told no. We moved to another table. We are a retired couple who were expecting a nice evening. Restrooms are filthy. Foodstraight from freezer to deep fryer. Won't be back

natalie-altemose-wee
17.02.2026

My mom grew up here in the 70s. I didn't have high hopes when she brought me. I was a jabroni. The pizza was delicious!! It was very calm and peaceful inside and everyone was nice to me. If you like homestyle Americana, you will not be disappointed. Very tasty, very relaxed, can't wait to come back to OH!

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.