Castaways - Lancaster

#2 - Fast Food - Lancaster, Pizza, American

Castaways

Castaways
4.3 / 5 (925 reviews)

Menu

On this webpage, you will find the complete menu of Castaways from Lancaster. Currently, there are 4 dishes and drinks available.

Dining at this restaurant is truly hit or miss, as evidenced by the wide range of reviews from disappointed customers to raving fans. Some complained of soggy pizza crusts and lackluster dishes, while others praised the delicious steaks and relaxed atmosphere. The service also seemed to be a point of contention, with some guests experiencing rudeness and slow service, while others were impressed by the friendly and quick service they received. Overall, it appears that this restaurant's success may depend on who's working that day and what dishes are ordered.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Glen

Images

Castaways Food Castaways Food Castaways Food Castaways Food Castaways Food

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 925 reviews

Was Waino Bartell at Castaways a mag?
my mother grew up in the 70s. I had no high hopes when she brought me. I was a jabroni. the pizza was delicious! it was very quiet and peaceful in the inner and everyone was nice to me. if they like homestyle americana, they will not be disappointed. very tasty, very relaxed, can't wait to get back to oh! View all feedback.

What Glen Ratke dislikes about Castaways:
Pizza crust was soaked in some kind of liquid and especially middle of crust was soggy and not edible. My wife's hashbrowns looked and tasted old or something? Salads had good dressings. Probably won't try it again. View all feedback.

cgalli
23.11.2017

Food was great, service was fantasticIt's kind of a hole in the wall type placeNothing fancy at allYou seat yourself.

jefferey48
23.11.2017

Food was very goodThe only negative was the attitude of the waitressesThey were on the rude side.

madalyn80
23.11.2017

I had gotten a coupon from restaurant.com for here, so my friend and I went the other night.

glen-328
26.06.2023

Pizza crust was soaked in some kind of liquid and especially middle of crust was soggy and not edible. My wife's hashbrowns looked and tasted old or something? Salads had good dressings. Probably won't try it again.

reynold-welch
20.09.2022

The best restaurant before place we have ever had the pleasure to eat! freshest meat I have ever put in my mouth best pizza ever great steaks! I loved the atmosphere cooking the smell of eating over the whole place.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.