Barnwood - Lagrange

#28 - Pizza - Lagrange, Family, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Barnwood

Barnwood
3.2 / 5 (219 reviews)

Description

Barnwood offers a unique blend of dining experiences, with patrons encountering both highlights and disappointments. While many rave about the delicious calamari, loaded mac and cheese, and generous portion sizes, others express frustration over long waits and lackluster flavors, particularly with certain entrees. Reservation challenges appear prevalent, as non-hotel guests often find themselves turned away despite empty tables. Service experiences vary widely, with some praising attentive staff, while others feel neglected. Overall, while Barnwood holds promise with its appealing dishes and family-friendly atmosphere, inconsistencies in food quality and service may leave some diners seeking alternatives.

Last update: 08.05.2026 from: Heather

Feedback

★ 3.2 / 5 from 219 reviews
heather-mitchell-tre
18.01.2024

The artichoke dip was absolutely delicious, and the portion size was perfect! The chicken and cheese quesadilla was fantastic—it disappeared in no time. My daughter ordered soup, and the serving was gigantic! My husband loved the loaded mac and cheese, which was really flavorful. The kids chose their usual favorites, a burger and grilled cheese, and they couldn't stop talking about the fries! For dessert, the kids opted for the strawberry shortcake. They were expecting a traditional layered shortcake, but what they got was far larger than they anticipated; had they known it would be so big, they would have shared it! Our waitress was lovely and even took some extra time to chat with my 7-year-old about Legos, which truly made his night. If we lived nearby, I would definitely come back to this restaurant even if I weren't staying at the property!

stefano-tanfulla
18.01.2024

I cannot recommend this restaurant. The service was incredibly slow—it's the worst I've ever experienced. After waiting an hour for our appetizer, we ended up canceling the order. We also asked for drink refills, which never came, as well as salt and pepper that were never provided. Although they did cover our entire bill, I still wouldn’t choose to return, especially given the high prices for dining at the lodge. The manager acknowledged our difficulties and offered an apology, but overall, this place simply isn’t worth the visit.

ruth-st-arre
18.01.2024

We visited on a busy night and could only get a reservation for 9:30 PM. The food took a long time to arrive, and we were quite hungry, but we tried to be patient. I ordered a full rack of ribs, but unfortunately, they were completely flavorless. The sauce tasted like it came straight from a bottle and was just slopped on without any care. The steak was also burnt. To be honest, I would recommend saving your money and going to "Buckets," where you can enjoy better burgers and similar dishes. I ended up spending $33 on the ribs, and I definitely had my expectations set too high.

stacey-miller-restau
18.01.2024

Initially, I was going to give 1 star, but kudos to the manager and the kind hostess for their excellent customer service. I placed a to-go order for the Quinoa Salad while the rest of my family ate pizza, thinking we had planned perfectly. I ordered at 5:45 and was told to return in 25-30 minutes. When I came back, they hadn’t started my order yet and asked me to come back in 15 more minutes. After returning again, it still wasn’t ready. I waited over an hour and asked once more. The manager then apologized, explaining the kitchen was overwhelmed and they had just started my appetizer. He gave me a discount on my meal, which I appreciated since waiting over an hour after being told 25 minutes wasn’t ideal. The dinner was great, and I would definitely eat here again. Hopefully, they can improve their timing so future customers don’t have to wait so long.

jen-salisbury
18.01.2024

The staff and food at Barnwood were outstanding. The receptionists and our server were incredibly kind, and the team who brought our food was fantastic. It was a truly wonderful experience. I was initially worried because of some other reviews, but it turned out to be excellent. My sister and I shared the Wild Mushroom Pappardelle, which was absolutely delicious! We started with the calamari appetizer, my two older sons enjoyed the 16 oz. Bone-in Ribeye, and the little ones had hamburgers, chicken fingers, and grilled cheese. Everything was perfect—thank you so much; it was definitely one of the highlights of our trip.

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the establishment at no extra cost.

There is a TV / screen on-site where sports are broadcast.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.