Sal's New York Pizza - KILL DEVIL HILLS

This is my first time to the Outer Banks. Came in on Saturday 7/9, saw the good reviews that Sal's received and they were within walking distance. This is my opinion but I felt the dough was dry and just an average pizza definitely not living up tothe reviews. I also got an order of barbeque wings that were kind of dry as well. They certainly needed more sauce; I'm usedto my wings swimming in sauce. Granted, I'm from Pittsburgh, PA and maybe that's just how we do things up there. I don't wantto criticize too much since they may have had an off day and I only tried them once but being that Jasper also had a fewnegative comments recently, you wonder if there is not something more going on.

Amazing and authentic NY-style pizza! It’s incredibly tasty, and the service is excellent! The large pizza is genuinely large! The mozzarella sticks are crispy and delicious too. This is our go-to spot for pizza in OBX!

So I 've been to Sal 's in the past and enjoyed the food. Today I order and I realize it is a holiday weekend but they take the order and I pay over the phone because it is such a large order. They tell me it would be an hour and 15 minutes. Get here atthe hour mark so that I 'm not getting cold pizzas. And what do I get told, i told you it would be an hour and a half . No youdidn 't and now you are being very rude about it. On top of that they tell me it 's going to be another 45 minutes. You close at9. So now it will be after closing time..... Good thing I already paid the $180 because I sure as heck would have gotten Sliceor one of the others to do the same order in half the time.

I would rate this restaurant higher than five stars because it was fantastic. I was responsible for Thursday night's dinner but couldn't attend the family event, so I decided to call Sal's NY Pizza for a catered order. They delivered right on time, if not a few minutes early, and the food was wonderful. Everyone loved it and was very impressed. I just had to share this experience, as Sal's will definitely be our go-to place whenever we're in North Carolina. Thank you for making me look good in front of our large family! We ordered a large quantity of wings with a variety of sauces, an antipasto platter, salad, and breadsticks with marinara. Everything was amazing!

On a positive note, we ordered Buffalo wings, and they were fantastic—perfectly prepared and served with blue cheese and celery. We also tried an Italian sub and a side of meatballs, which were both excellent. The sub was well-made and came with tater tots, and the meatballs were delicious, accompanied by a nicely sliced Italian roll. While I wouldn’t recommend the pizza from Sal's New York Pizza due to the lack of a homemade crust, the other dishes were definitely enjoyable.