Casey's - Jacksonville

Pizza, Breakfast, Lunch
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
4.1 / 5 (352 reviews)

Description

A bustling neighborhood convenience restaurant praised for its friendly staff, large selection and popular pizza (not strictly authentic Italian). Patrons value its late-night takeout and sandwiches, but experiences vary: long waits, small portions, occasional stale bread, order and receipt errors, and inconsistent staff courtesy. Cleanliness and restroom upkeep have been questioned, and some menu prices feel high. Despite flaws, many locals keep returning for the convenience and regular pizza nights.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Kristina

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 352 reviews
mayert-meghan
01.05.2023

While some menu items could be a bit more affordable, this is a surprisingly large convenience store. I really love their pizza, though I wouldn't classify it as authentic Italian (but is that really found in the USA?). The staff are helpful and friendly.

clemens10
01.05.2023

The staff here are extremely friendly. D-Worker prepares the best pizza! Additionally, the blueberry coffee is fantastic.

eleanore41-bank4
01.05.2023

This is an excellent restaurant. The staff is consistently friendly, and the place is very clean. I really enjoy having pizza at night here. I'm grateful it's in my neighborhood.

kristina-r-teacher42
19.08.2024

This place has a lot to offer, but the long lines are frustrating. I know they have more than one employee, so I wonder where everyone is.

mike-c-flower8
19.08.2024

I requested a receipt at Pump after waiting in line for 12 minutes, but they refused to provide one. Instead, I received a receipt for a different pump. When I returned inside to address the issue, the attendant became quite rude. Additionally, the restroom was in terrible condition, resembling the aftermath of a toilet paper fight. Overall, I was very disappointed with my visit.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.