The Gatsby

Reviews

Overall Total Score

3 out of 5

Good | 1 reviews

What Jo Ann Falletta likes about The Gatsby:
A historic mansion with several different dining rooms and bar. The atmosphere is very comfortable and classy but not over the top. The calamari was mouth watering the best I 've had in a very long time. Salads are unique and delicious. The Rib eye steak was cooked to perfection with delicious flavor! Definitely worth the trip. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Jessica

01.11.2023 - 13:06

They have your typical Italian food which was good but nothing amazing. I had the potato gnocchi in pesto sauce. It was a pretty small serving for pasta. I get...

01.11.2023 - 13:06

A historic mansion with several different dining rooms and bar. The atmosphere is very comfortable and classy but not over the top. The calamari was mouth water...

Last update : 01.11.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Islip

Tellers An American Chophouse

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Islip, 605 Main StreetNY 11751, Islip, United States

"Food was delicious. Service was excellent"

##15 Seafood in Islip

Details

#15 Seafood in Islip

Sobol

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Islip, 3 Grant Ave, Islip, NY 11751-3500, United States, Afghanistan

"My family and I (vegan) love sobol. all their smoothies and shells are vegan without honey, but I don't think their waffles are. they offer vegan prot..."

##12 Vegetarian in Islip

Details

#12 Vegetarian in Islip Waffles Soup

Sobol

4.8

City: Lake Ronkonkoma (near Islip), 239 Hawkins Ave, 11779-4265, Lake Ronkonkoma, United States

"Love love them. Glad they came to Ronkonkoma!!!!!!"

##2 Cafés in Lake Ronkonko...

Details

#2 Cafés in Lake Ronkonkoma

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Deer Park (near Islip), 512 Commack Rd, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA, United States

"Outstanding Food and Service!"

##34 Fast Food in Deer Par...

Details

#34 Fast Food in Deer Park Catering

Milano Bean Cafe

4.8

City: East Islip (near Islip), 51 W Main St, 11730, East Islip, US, United States

"Everything I've had..best Americano ."

##9 Cafés in East Islip

Details

#9 Cafés in East Islip

Ralph's Italian Ices

4.9

Table booking

4.9

Table booking

City: Farmingville (near Islip), 623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, United States

"Large portions, yummy food highly recommend california wrap !"

##23 Pizza in Farmingville

Details

#23 Pizza in Farmingville

Basil Cafe

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: St James (near Islip), 413 Lake Ave, St James I-11780-2207, United States

"Great place, you will need reservations and it is b.y.o.b."

##9 Seafood in St James

Details

#9 Seafood in St James Vegetarian

Savor Eatery

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Bay Shore (near Islip), 631 E Main St, Bay Shore, United States

"Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4"

#Salads

Details

Salads Asian Delivery Services Salad

Carvel

4.8

City: Lake Ronkonkoma (near Islip), 386 Portion Rd, 11779-2356, Lake Ronkonkoma, United States

"This restaurant is always a great choice! As a resident of North Carolina, I can't find Carvel ice cream anymore. Whenever I'm in New York, it's a mus..."

#Desserts

Details

Desserts Bakeries Great Dessert