Lorelei - ISLAMORADA
Menu
The restaurant from ISLAMORADA offers 85 different dishes and drinks on the menu for an average price of $10.3.
Nestled by the water, Lorelei offers a vibrant atmosphere that attracts many diners. While some guests rave about the exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes—like the fish sandwich and key lime pie—others lament disappointing meals characterized by bland flavors and inadequate service. A few diners also encountered unwelcoming staff and mishaps during their visits. Despite the inconsistency, the restaurant remains popular, boasting a picturesque setting and diverse menu. For those looking for a delightful lunch or evening vibe, Lorelei has potential, but expectations should be managed based on recent experiences.
Images
Feedback
Was User at Lorelei a mag?
Sitting for dinner on Sunday night, but could not sit for a while. Came back to lunch on a boat of Robbie rented and LOVED it much more than expected! The food was excellent! Had Raw Tuna Nachos for an appetizer and seafood tacos. Delicious! The location is beach casual during the day. Sunsets are spectacular. Definitely worth a stop in the keys. View all feedback.
What John A dislikes about Lorelei:
Save your time and money and skip dinner at Lorelei. Instead, head there around sunset for a drink and enjoy the view. The food was disappointing and well below average. We were a group of 11... View all feedback.
Been here many times. During busy nites you may have to hawk out a table, bc there is no hostess. Free entertainment , open to outside, sunsets, great...
Had a great time there last night. Excellent entertainment, the singer was amazing on guitar. The best shrimp Quesadilla I've ever had!
Ate there last night beautiful sunset, great food and live music; toped with good service and reasonable prices ... A must visit when in the area.. Go...
The restaurant was closed, yet there was a group of people inside drinking. As we approached, a woman yelled, “We are closed, come back tomorrow.” We just wanted to take some beautiful sunset photos. We noticed a couple had walked to the back to take pictures, so I followed suit. However, one of the guys in the drinking group said, “No, we are closed,” even though he had just let the couple before me take their pictures. It felt unfair and possibly even racially motivated. We were really disappointed and will definitely not be returning, nor will we recommend this place to our family and friends.
The lobster tails were a bit overcooked, and the sauce for my boyfriend 's catch of the day could use more flavor. On the bright side, I really enjoyed the key lime drink and the beautiful sunset view.
Full Menu
Entrées
Lorelei's Smoked Fish Dip$8.0 Sunset Conch Fritters$8.3 Fresh Home Made Mozzarella$9.0Soups
Keys Conch Chowder$6.0Starters
Choice 12Oz New York Strip Steak$22.2 Bayside Grilled Chiken$15.1
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.8 / 5 (2525 reviews)#12 Seafood in ISLAMORADA AmericanTwisted Shrimp
Overseas Hwy 87745, 33036-3093 ISLAMORADA, US
"If there were a rating of 10 stars, we would give this restaurant a perfect score! The shrimp plate was fresh and delicious. My companion had the shri..."
★ 4.9 / 5 (1826 reviews)Cocktail Brewery Fish Beer DrinksIslamorada Brewery Distillery (islamorada)
82229 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, USA, ISLAMORADA, United States
"Cool brewery/distillery. Beer was good with quite a few tropical flavor options. We were so impressed with the sample of the magic mermaid gin drink a..."
★ 4.8 / 5 (1023 reviews)#2 Vegetarian in ISLAMORADAOff The Hook Churrascaria
Oversea Hwy 82205, 33036 ISLAMORADA, US
"Amazing food! Great taste of seasonings used?Wonderful service!!"