Lorelei - ISLAMORADA
Lorelei
Description
Nestled by the water, Lorelei offers a vibrant atmosphere that attracts many diners. While some guests rave about the exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes—like the fish sandwich and key lime pie—others lament disappointing meals characterized by bland flavors and inadequate service. A few diners also encountered unwelcoming staff and mishaps during their visits. Despite the inconsistency, the restaurant remains popular, boasting a picturesque setting and diverse menu. For those looking for a delightful lunch or evening vibe, Lorelei has potential, but expectations should be managed based on recent experiences.
Images
Feedback
The restaurant was closed, yet there was a group of people inside drinking. As we approached, a woman yelled, “We are closed, come back tomorrow.” We just wanted to take some beautiful sunset photos. We noticed a couple had walked to the back to take pictures, so I followed suit. However, one of the guys in the drinking group said, “No, we are closed,” even though he had just let the couple before me take their pictures. It felt unfair and possibly even racially motivated. We were really disappointed and will definitely not be returning, nor will we recommend this place to our family and friends.
The lobster tails were a bit overcooked, and the sauce for my boyfriend 's catch of the day could use more flavor. On the bright side, I really enjoyed the key lime drink and the beautiful sunset view.
I went there for dinner around 6 PM, but it was more of a drinking spot than a dining one. I never felt so unwelcome in a restaurant before, so we decided to leave.
Always a beautiful sunset
Amazing food, service, and scenery. Doesn’t get better than that!! My fiancé and I had the conch fritters, crab chowder, mahi tacos and snapper sandwich. I recommend the chowder for a light but delicious app! Topped it all off with their famous key lime pie. Service was also quick and pleasant! 10/10 Will be coming back
Menu
Entrées
Fresh Home Made Mozzarellacrunchy outside; creamy inside melts in your mouth. laid over homemade spicy marinara
$8.9Starters
Choice 12Oz New York Strip Steakchar grilled to your taste; served + chips; fries / keys rice pilaf & sauteed seasonal vegetables
$21.9 Bayside Grilled Chikenmarinated overnight & basted + your choice of teriyaki sauce + grilled pineapple / parmesan peppercorn; both served over keys rice pilaf + sauteed vegetables
$14.9Sandwiches
Lorelei World Famous Madeira Bay Fish Sandwichfresh catch of the day grilled; blackened / fried + lettuce tomato & onion
$9.9 Peppercorn Parmesan Chicken Sandwichmarinated; grilled chicken breast basted + parmesan peppercorn dressing + provolone & bacon; served + lettuce; tomato & onion
$8.9Soups
Keys Conch Chowder$5.9
Menu PDF
FAQ
More information
QR-Code for the menu
