Harry & Izzy's - Indianapolis

I rated 3 and my boyfriend rated 4 stars. We both ordered filet mignon. He got the mashed potatoes and I got the green beans. We also got the famous shrimp cocktail. Compliment sandwich here… the sides were very tasty and not overly done with oil or butter. The rolls were good with lots of butter. I really enjoyed the shrimp cocktail, but you MUST be a fan of horseradish. My boyfriend did not like it at all, but he dislikes horseradish. The cocktail sauce had a quick sharp bite to it, so get ready. I gave Harry and Izzy’s 3 stars because I am a steak snob. I love to cook and rarely eat out because I make things the way I like. I ordered a medium rare steak. For over $50, I would have expected it to be correctly cooked. It was well done and not good. In my opinion, a well done steak is a great way to ruin a steak. My boyfriend likes his steak burnt to a crisp and he liked it. He thought it had a lot of flavor. The waitress did send the manager over, but I’m not into giving a second chance on a first impression with food. The atmosphere was nice. I had a very good Cabernet Sauvignon (I got the Justin, Paso Rubles). I don’t think I will eat here again unless I have gift card.

Our waiter Seth was the best, very accommodating, polite and helpful! We had the Alfredo with chicken and shrimp and it was delicious! Overall I rate our experience 10/10

We haven’t been to this restaurant for several years. Finally decided to try it. Steak was done perfectly and delicious, salmon, the same. Service was excellent and a very comfortable atmosphere. We will go back.

Food was fantastic! Waitress was also, until she wasn't...

Awesome dinner and service. Our waitress Diamond was top notch. We are looking forward to dining there again in the very near future