Casey's - Heyworth

Breakfast, Lunch, Lunch

Casey's

Casey's
3.6 / 5 (203 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Casey's from Heyworth featuring all 4 dishes and drinks can be found here on the list.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: mike

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 203 reviews

Was GARY ESTRADA at Casey's a mag?
Usual Casey's, good tasting donuts, dinner pizza and breakfast pizza is good, as are the cheeseburgers and breakfast sandwiches. Wide selection of snacks and drinks. Polite, courteous staff. Conveniently located just off highway 51 and near Bloomington. View all feedback.

What Christopher Shaffer dislikes about Casey's:
The lady behind the counter is really lazy she was sitting in a chair stalking stuff and she is young now the workers back there cooking they did exactly what they were told they did the right thing they were actually cooking it's just the lady behind the counter at the cash register was very lazy and sitting in a chair while paying me out. In Heyworth Illinois Casey's View all feedback.

kumar-patel-1
10.11.2023

I was simply parked in front of the restaurant, waiting for my phone to charge in my running vehicle in 20-degree weather, when the employees called the police on me. I had my child and dog with me, so I couldn't understand why they felt the need to involve the authorities. Was it because of the color of my skin? I have never had such an experience at a gas station or Casey's before. This is unacceptable, they need to do better.

kimi-oest
10.11.2023

We were welcomed with joy as soon as we entered, with a warm smile and a friendly hello! Mindy prepared our sandwiches, which were incredibly delicious, and even provided us with new sandwich wrappers to prevent them from falling apart. The customer service was fantastic and the staff were very friendly. This place makes the best sub sandwiches; I will no longer be going to Subway if there is a Casey's nearby. I highly recommend this restaurant!

gary
10.11.2023

Usual Casey's, good tasting donuts, dinner pizza and breakfast pizza is good, as are the cheeseburgers and breakfast sandwiches. Wide selection of snacks and drinks. Polite, courteous staff. Conveniently located just off highway 51 and near Bloomington.

mike-mullen-3
04.03.2025

Always a busy place while I'm mowing, I love caseys great pizza and always a staff you can joke with, nobody likes a robot at the register.

chris-shook-cat9714
04.03.2025

No waiting good service Service: Take out Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.