Mary's - Herrin

American, Seafood, Soup
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Mary's.

Mary's

Mary's
4.9 / 5 (704 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Mary's from Herrin featuring all 25 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Mary's Restaurant, located in a charming Victorian-style home originally built in 1896, offers a unique dining experience with a blend of tradition and modernity. Owned by David and Carla Hays since 1992, this establishment also includes a cozy bed and breakfast next door. The menu at Mary's Restaurant features a rotating selection of classic dishes, contemporary creations, and special specialties. Indulge in dishes such as Alaskan king crab, succulent shrimp, flavorful lobster, fresh fish, and a variety of premium meat options like USDA prime beef, lamb, pork, chicken, duck, and ostrich. Whether you visit for lunch, dinner, or as a guest at the bed and breakfast, Mary's Restaurant promises a memorable culinary experience. Conveniently situated in the heart of Herrin on the west side of Route 148, Mary's Restaurant is a destination worth exploring.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: jentle

Images

Mary's Food Mary's Inside Mary's Food Mary's Outside

Reservation request for Mary's

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.9 / 5 from 704 reviews

Mary's restaurant has impressed diners with its great food, elegant atmosphere, and exceptional service. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, providing a high-quality dining experience. The menu offers delicious options, from escargot to seafood bisque to perfectly cooked steaks. While prices may be higher, customers believe the experience and food are well worth it. With servers like Trent and Nick providing excellent service, Mary's is a favorite spot for many. Whether celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, diners consistently praise the food, ambiance, and top-notch service.

pat-600
14.08.2023

The service, ambiance, and food at this restaurant were excellent. My wife ordered the swordfish with jalapeño and pineapple, while I opted for the molasses and espresso steak. Both dishes were fantastic and cooked perfectly (they nailed the medium rare steak!). It's not easy to find a place that cooks steak this well around here. We will definitely be returning without a doubt.

bonnie-41
14.08.2023

My husband and I celebrated my birthday at Mary's. We were both very impressed. Everything was perfect! The host gave us a warm, friendly greeting and seated us right away. The ambiance was great and we loved the decor. Our server was amazing! We didn't wait for anything but our appetizer, salads, entrees, and desserts were all served to us at a much more leisurely pace than other restaurants. We didn't feel rushed at all to hurry up and eat so they could clear the table and move the next party in. We were able to thoroughly enjoy our meal. It was wonderful!! And the food, OMG!! The shrimp and lobster were most definitely fresh, never frozen. The steak knives they gave us weren't necessary. The steaks were so juicy and tender you could cut them with a butter knife and they melted in our mouths. It was all deliciously seasoned and cooked to perfection! Last but not least, the best cheesecake ever! Hat's off to everyone at Mary's and thank you for making my birthday extra special.

chad-104
14.08.2023

The service was excellent and the food was amazing! The escargot was the best I've ever had and the duck breast was incredibly delicious. The seared scallops in drawn butter were cooked to perfection and simply melted in your mouth. Thank you for a wonderful evening!

jentle
14.08.2023

Very clean and friendly environment. Smiles as you walk in the door, very elegant as well, we didn't expect them to take our coats and hang them up . We had a excellent waiter, Trent if I remember correctly, shout out to you bro, my wife and I enjoyed you, broke the menu down well and very friendly. We got what we paid for, great food and great service.

stephanie-374
14.08.2023

Very nice, quiet location with high quality food. I tried Swordfish today, different but great! Seafood Soup and Croissant was delicious

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.