Rustler's Bbq - Henryetta

This place is our go to place anytime we are in the area. We stopped there coming back from Hot Springs. It was Mother?s Day was still good. Next month we will... read more This place is our go to place anytime we are in the area. We stopped there coming back from Hot Springs. It was Mother?s Day was still good. Next month we will be back for some bologna! It?s the absolute best! The place is so nice friendly staff. If anyone is ever in the area, it?s well worth the stop to eat. You won?t be disappointed.

Very good food and great staff! I was a bit surprised at the cost of a brisket dinner (almost $20) but the quality and quantity are so good I'm not complaining.... read more Very good food and great staff! I was a bit surprised at the cost of a brisket dinner (almost $20) but the quality and quantity are so good I'm not complaining. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is great as well. Top notch place I will definitely recommend to others!

Great atmosphere here. Was going to try the spicy Ruben just because I like Ruben?s. The girl at the counter wasn?t real convincing to get it. I told her I want... read more Great atmosphere here. Was going to try the spicy Ruben just because I like Ruben?s. The girl at the counter wasn?t real convincing to get it. I told her I wanted to try lots of stuff then. Guy behind me told me to get the 5 meat platter. Ended up going with his recommendation. But I added some chop and a couple of ribs. Cost me $40.00 for what?s pictured. At first I felt like that was way too much money for what I was getting. But when it came out, I could have easily shared that with someone and we would have both been full. The bbq is good. It?s not great, but it was good. They have a pretty neat sauce dispenser. It?s like milking a cow! Lolol. Wish I would have gotten pics of that. Super friendly place. I was just passing through and seen that it had 4.7 stars. I was hoping for some better smoke flavor, but some don?t like too much smoke. I like to taste the flavor of the wood used. I would recommend going there. Seemed like really nice people behind the counter and place was very clean. Clean restrooms as well. I left full and left with a pretty big To go box.

Absolutely delicious! The atmosphere is charming and the food is fantastic. I highly recommend this place, especially for meat lovers. I tried the Moabb, and it... read more Absolutely delicious! The atmosphere is charming and the food is fantastic. I highly recommend this place, especially for meat lovers. I tried the Moabb, and it was wonderful. My boyfriend, who has a sensitive stomach, had some difficulty with the hot links, but other than that, everything was great. If you have a tendency to get stomach issues from certain meats like bologna or hot dogs, just keep that in mind. Their BBQ sauce is also delicious. Overall, it was an amazing experience and definitely a highlight of the town.

This restaurant is amazing! We discovered it by chance while traveling and decided to give it a try. The food is outstanding. We ordered the spicy pork tacos wi... read more This restaurant is amazing! We discovered it by chance while traveling and decided to give it a try. The food is outstanding. We ordered the spicy pork tacos with potato dip fries, the BBQ melt topped with Doritos, and the chopped brisket sandwich accompanied by Lay's chips. It was absolutely worth the detour from I-40! We enjoyed the meal so much that I completely forgot to take any pictures!