Reviews
What Amy Lee likes about Tiki Man Pizza:
So good that we came back the next night to try more on the menu! Very Hawaii atmosphere and clearly a local's establishment. The vibe is laid back with live music and happy hour. They split the menu into forks v knives, which is a nice touch for the veggie peeps or people searching for some greens on vacation. Super friendly staff and timely service. View all feedback. What Jason T doesn't like about Tiki Man Pizza:
This place is a hard pass people. In an otherwise island devoid of good food, this place is beyond bad. Please avoid as the food here is beyond poor. The frozen oven style pizza at Foodlands is Michelin star resto compared to this hovel. I feel for these guys as they have been around for 60 years per the hostess. Sad thing is, longevity doesn't equal quality. Find pizza somewhere else. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
This place is a hard pass people. In an otherwise island devoid of good food, this place is beyond bad. Please avoid as the food here is beyond poor. The frozen...
read moreThe absolute best pizza ever, great crispy crust, fresh tomatoes, rich great sauce. Our favorite ever.. maybe even better than pizza we had in Italy
We ordered a pizza. But of course when we walked in the tall blonde. Made sure she said. In a not so nice tone. We only serve pizza now. Is that okay. But of co...
read moreI am not sure how this pizzeria is still open. I had the most disgusting and expensive Pizza in my life there. Before ordering the Pizza, I asked how big the Pi...
read moreWe called to place a phone order and were told to hold, then the woman put the phone down and I waited for 27 minutes before hanging up. I heard background nois...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreDespite mixed reviews, this pizzeria in the north shore of the island has stood the test of time, having been around for 60 years. While some diners were disappointed with the quality and size of the pizza, others found the vibe to be laid back with live music and friendly staff. The Mai Tai cocktails, Ono fish roll appetizer, Zesty coconut catch, and macadamia nut crusted chicken were highlights for many visitors. The restaurant is known for staying open late compared to other places in the area, making it a popular spot for visitors looking for a late-night bite. Overall, despite a few hiccups, HANALEI Bay Pizzeria seems to offer a unique dining experience with its local charm and tasty dishes.
We had to wait 45 minutes for lunch, but so well worth it! The place was slammed and the staff really worked their butts off, all the while staying friendly and...
read moreI highly recommend the pizza coconut shrimp! Very delicious and they have great happy hour prices. Service was top notch!
A place to check out ! FYI they open later in the day but are one of a few places around north shore of the island that stay open until like 11pm every where el...
read moreOk, the ahi carpaccio was the best meal I've had on the north shore. I wish I could take it home with me. My husband got the coconut prawns and loved it, too! D...
read moreSo good that we came back the next night to try more on the menu! Very Hawaii atmosphere and clearly a local's establishment. The vibe is laid back with live mu...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreWe ordered a pizzaBut of course when we walked in the tall blondeMade sure she saidIn a not so nice tone We only serve pizza nowIs that okay.
I am not sure how this pizzeria is still openI had the most disgusting and expensive Pizza in my life there.
The absolute best pizza ever, great crispy crust, fresh tomatoes, rich great sauce. Our favorite ever.. maybe even better than pizza we had in Italy
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more