Cowfish - Hampton Bays

Went for dinner. Were seated promptly. Service was attentive. My issue was mainly with the bar. Drinks were slow and who ever made my espresso martini did not k... read more Went for dinner. Were seated promptly. Service was attentive. My issue was mainly with the bar. Drinks were slow and who ever made my espresso martini did not know what they were doing. Small martini glass maybe 2/3 full, I received about 2 oz of liquid with more then half of what little liquid was there was froth. Honestly 3 sips. Oh and they charged me extra for baileys. So off to a bad start, I ordered spinach artichoke dip. It was good but not enough chips, had to ask for more. Ordered an old fashioned, again small, and in place of a luxardo cherry (my favorite part) was a maraschino (let down again) cherry Ordered the filet with loaded baked potato. I don’t mind paying $58 for filet but to the Charge $6 extra for fois gras butter was kind of steep for a 2 oz. Ramekin. Ate all my food, and my girlfriend got salmon which she enjoyed. we then went upstairs for one last drink on the deck, ordered another old fashioned to try again at the upstairs bar hoping it was just the bar tender. I thought downstairs bar tender was bad, upstairs was even worse, honestly the worst old fashioned I’ve ever had, it looked Ike aperol spritz, and tasted like there was no whiskey. $20 I want a glass of whiskey with a cherry not some nasty juice with an orange peel. Bar tender then proceeded to charge me for the wrong persons bill $63 for my old fashion which I was upcharge to $20 for makers which i couldn’t taste it was like vermouth and citrus juice with an orange peel. Bartender clueless. Had to tell bartender they made a mistake with bull at which point they said sorry we gave u someone else’s ticket. not impressed u charge too much to mess up this bad 3 drinks all disappointing, first one very slow, all over priced and very very little alcohol. If I spend $250 I want to at least leave with a buzz, I wouldn’t go back. If your gonna charge $20 for a drink train your bar staff Amateur Hour

Our waitress was Daniella. She was a pure delight. Hope we have her again. Had appetizers and lunch. As always, the food is delicious. Service: Dine in Meal typ... read more Our waitress was Daniella. She was a pure delight. Hope we have her again. Had appetizers and lunch. As always, the food is delicious. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

We went for lunch for the first time on a recommendation from a friend. ALL I CAN SAY IS, WOW!!! The food, service and ambiance was all “top notch”. Our waiter... read more We went for lunch for the first time on a recommendation from a friend. ALL I CAN SAY IS, WOW!!! The food, service and ambiance was all “top notch”. Our waiter Anthony was phenomenal and the food and beverage manager, Jacob was beyond helpful. They did not have a particular wine that my mother liked so he recommended a drink that he made, and it was out of this world. I believe it was an autumn sangria, he came to the table to see if my mother liked it, He talked to us for quite some time and really made us feel welcome at the restaurant. Anthony recommended some dishes and the desserts and everything was perfect. I cannot recommend this restaurant enough thank you Anthony and Jacob for a wonderful experience with your restaurant. We can’t wait to come back.

Try the Buffalo shrimp Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 read more Try the Buffalo shrimp Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Well we went as a party of 12. Its off season so that might be why there was a small menu, very limited. Nice outside grounds right on the wzter ,boats etc.. Fo... read more Well we went as a party of 12. Its off season so that might be why there was a small menu, very limited. Nice outside grounds right on the wzter ,boats etc.. Food was nothing special , my steak was ok, the giant baked potatoe was cold and the service was slow. I wouldnt send people there during the off season. Food: 3 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4