Carvel - Hampton Bays

Most unenthusiastic staff ever. The guy got our order wrong because he had earbuds in. Was going to buy some oreo ice cream sandwiches that are in the freezer n... read more Most unenthusiastic staff ever. The guy got our order wrong because he had earbuds in. Was going to buy some oreo ice cream sandwiches that are in the freezer near the register until I realized they were all half full of ice cream because they hadmelted before being refrozen. When I asked if they had any that hadn 't melted they told me no. Because that 's just how theyare Way too expensive for such poor service and low quality ice cream.

Best soft serve ice cream ever read more Best soft serve ice cream ever

The staff is young but great!! Haven't had this illusive sandy texture from their hard serve ice cream but have had their soft serve be a bit too soft sometimes... read more The staff is young but great!! Haven't had this illusive sandy texture from their hard serve ice cream but have had their soft serve be a bit too soft sometimes but still, great ice cream overall. Only place I'll come for pistachio and mint chip ice cream too. Totally reminds me of my summers as a kid when getting a huge ice cream cone from carvel for a dollar was a huge treat and something to look forward to.

I guess I'm starting to feel nostalgic. I recall when I was a kid, getting Carvel Ice Cream Cones for just 25 cents. read more I guess I'm starting to feel nostalgic. I recall when I was a kid, getting Carvel Ice Cream Cones for just 25 cents.

The staff at this restaurant lacked enthusiasm. Our order was wrong because the server was wearing earbuds. I intended to buy some Oreo ice cream sandwiches fro... read more The staff at this restaurant lacked enthusiasm. Our order was wrong because the server was wearing earbuds. I intended to buy some Oreo ice cream sandwiches from the freezer near the register, but I noticed they were all partially melted. When I asked if I could get a different one, I was informed that they were out of stock. Overall, this experience did not justify the high prices considering the poor service and low-quality ice cream.