Highwayman - Halifax

I visited this restaurant with three friends, and our experience was extremely disappointing. We arrived at 8 PM and had to wait for more than two hours for our... read more I visited this restaurant with three friends, and our experience was extremely disappointing. We arrived at 8 PM and had to wait for more than two hours for our orders to finally arrive. What made it worse was that each of us received our dishes separately, which made the evening far from enjoyable.To make matters even worse, there was an incident when I took my glass of wine outdoors to smoke. A female waiter, (illustrated on the postcard given to us with the bill) approached me quite aggressively and attempted to grab my glass of wine without properly explaining the rules. Given the recent global pandemic, I expected a higher level of awareness and hygiene from the staff. This experience was far from what one would hope for, especially in Halifax, Canada. One star is generous for such a disappointing visit.I would strongly advise against dining at this establishment. Not only was the service shockingly slow, but it was also incredibly overpriced. Our group ended up spending nearly $250, and what we received in return was subpar food portions and unacceptable service. This experience left a sour taste in our mouths, both figuratively and literally. One star is more than this place deserves.

We came here for happy hour and had the best time! Oysters were so so tasty, we got to try three different types from around the maritimes, and the cocktails we... read more We came here for happy hour and had the best time! Oysters were so so tasty, we got to try three different types from around the maritimes, and the cocktails were insanely good. The vibes were also excellent, decor is so charming and welcoming and the playlist was top tier. Highly recommend for fellow cocktail lovers!Food: 5/5

So good! We went for happy hour and it's an absolute steal. If this place was in Paris, NY, LA, etc. it would be absolutely packed from 4 to 5. Excellent platte... read more So good! We went for happy hour and it's an absolute steal. If this place was in Paris, NY, LA, etc. it would be absolutely packed from 4 to 5. Excellent platters and oysters, $10 cocktails, and a cool but unpretentious vibe. We'll definitely be back!Food: 5/5

Don’t count on this place for any important reservations. If it’s an important occasion (birthday, graduation, important date) reserve at any restaurant except... read more Don’t count on this place for any important reservations. If it’s an important occasion (birthday, graduation, important date) reserve at any restaurant except this one. I was supposed to eat here last night. I made my reservation two weeks in advance. The dinner was a special occasion, which I explained in a note when I made the reservation. When we arrived the restaurant was closed. It is absurd that this 15-table restaurant can’t call people who have reservations to tell them that the restaurant is closed. I’ve eaten here several times in the past and it is good by Halifax standards. But it isn’t worth the risk and the awful customer service. Food: 3 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3

We chose The Highwayman to celebrate our son’s high school graduation, trusting its place among Nova Scotia’s Top 25 restaurants for 2024 by Curated Halifax Mag... read more We chose The Highwayman to celebrate our son’s high school graduation, trusting its place among Nova Scotia’s Top 25 restaurants for 2024 by Curated Halifax Magazine. Unfortunately, it was a deeply disappointing experience. From the moment we arrived—15 minutes late due to traffic—we were told we’d need to vacate in 90 minutes, with no flexibility or warmth. The table was by the window with no shades or curtains in direct sunlight on a 26°C day, and when we asked about it, our server responded dismissively that she “doesn’t control the weather”. No offer to move us, despite visible empty tables. The food was underwhelming. Two separate dishes came with black hairs in them (we’re all blondes). My main was served cold with undercooked rice. No one checked on our table once, besides adding water which was spilled on us twice. The server left mid-meal and was replaced by someone else. Nobody introduced themselves either. We noted our celebration in the reservation—completely ignored. For a restaurant ranked so highly, the lack of professionalism, care, and basic hygiene was shocking. This was meant to be a special night. It turned into a major disappointment for a family of 4 and a complete waste of almost $300. Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2 Price per person: $100+