Schlabach Bakery - Guthrie

Excellent selection of pie and cakes and bread. Had to wait for someone to wait on us about 10 mins. Gentleman in back did not know cashier was outside. Must be... read more Excellent selection of pie and cakes and bread. Had to wait for someone to wait on us about 10 mins. Gentleman in back did not know cashier was outside. Must be new owners or something.

Used to visit this bakery with my mom who passed away in 2001. We were in Tennessee for Easter with family and decided to ride up. Memories sure flood back turn... read more Used to visit this bakery with my mom who passed away in 2001. We were in Tennessee for Easter with family and decided to ride up. Memories sure flood back turning into the parking lot and the smell of freshly baked goods were pure nostalgia.Got lots of goodies to fill our bellies although one loaf of the bread didn't make it back to the house 30 minutes away. We pulled it off in chunks just like mom and I used to do. <3

Everything here is just so yummy! If I worked there I would get big as a whale! ? Highly recommend it, you won’t regret it for sure! read more Everything here is just so yummy! If I worked there I would get big as a whale! ? Highly recommend it, you won’t regret it for sure!

Delicious baked goods and excellent customer service. For larger orders, it's best to call a day or two in advance, as this is a small Amish business with homem... read more Delicious baked goods and excellent customer service. For larger orders, it's best to call a day or two in advance, as this is a small Amish business with homemade pastries baked on-site. Especially during the holidays, purchasing from them is a great time saver and definitely worth the short drive.

Schlabach Bakery is truly outstanding. Everything they offer is delicious. We especially love their Fried Pies, with Apple and Peach as our top picks. Everythin... read more Schlabach Bakery is truly outstanding. Everything they offer is delicious. We especially love their Fried Pies, with Apple and Peach as our top picks. Everything is made from scratch using high-quality ingredients. We’ve also enjoyed their cinnamon rolls, brownies, oatmeal cream pies, chocolate pies, lemon bars, sourdough bread, and their pure 100% honey.