Reviews
What Jerry S doesn't like about Catherine's:
The vegetarian options were limited, but it didn’t really matter since the food itself was disappointing. I ordered a pasta dish with mushrooms and tomatoes, while my wife opted for chicken marsala. We received hefty portions, but the quality left much to be desired. We decided to skip dessert, and both of us experienced uncomfortable stomach aches afterward—I'll spare you the details. We won’t be returning. Addition... View all feedback. What Christina D likes about Catherine's:
The food is always consistently excellent, and the service matches that quality. I really enjoy the atmosphere! The staff is very friendly, and you definitely won't be disappointed. The prices for the food are reasonable too. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Catherine's is the perfect choice! The food is absolutely fantastic, and the staff is even better! We've been visiting Catherine's for years, and every time, it...
read moreWhat a delightful and unique spot! I absolutely adore the bar downstairs, which was bustling with locals who have been frequenting the place for years. The port...
read moreWow, I'm amazed by this restaurant! I've been coming here for over a year, and I'm not sure why I always thought everything was perfect.
Always consistent food. The service is also consistently loving the atmosphere! Very friendly staff. They won't be disappointed. Average prices also for food.
Great service. good menu. I love the cellar.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreGood eats, great portions! Would come here again anytime' price reasonably. The locations makes it feel very authentic!!!
Great hospitality, delicious food, large portions. What more could we ask for? Highly recommend this restaurant.
The food is always consistently excellent, and the service matches that quality. I really enjoy the atmosphere! The staff is very friendly, and you definitely w...
read moreThe vegetarian options were limited, but it didn’t really matter since the food itself was disappointing. I ordered a pasta dish with mushrooms and tomatoes, wh...
read moreWe had a very disappointing experience. Our table was located near the bus station, which meant we were constantly interrupted by waitresses rushing past. The n...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe food, service, pricing, and atmosphere are all outstanding! Owners Steve and Jennifer are wonderful hosts who truly take pride in their restaurant, the qual...
read moreWe visited Catherine's after spending the day at Legoland in Goshen. The food at Catherine's is fantastic, and the portions are incredibly generous. Although we...
read moreWhat a delightful and unique spot! I really enjoyed the bar on the lower level, which was bustling with locals who clearly have been frequenting this place for...
read moreGreat service, food. Each portion is HUGE
Great like always
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe food is excellent, but the atmosphere is extremely loud and crowded.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more