Catherine's - Goshen

The food is always consistently excellent, and the service matches that quality. I really enjoy the atmosphere! The staff is very friendly, and you definitely w... read more The food is always consistently excellent, and the service matches that quality. I really enjoy the atmosphere! The staff is very friendly, and you definitely won't be disappointed. The prices for the food are reasonable too.

What a delightful and unique spot! I really enjoyed the bar on the lower level, which was bustling with locals who clearly have been frequenting this place for... read more What a delightful and unique spot! I really enjoyed the bar on the lower level, which was bustling with locals who clearly have been frequenting this place for years. The portion sizes were enormous, and the food was expertly prepared. The pasta tasted incredibly fresh, almost as if it were homemade. I can't wait to come back and sample more dishes!

The vegetarian options were limited, but it didn’t really matter since the food itself was disappointing. I ordered a pasta dish with mushrooms and tomatoes, wh... read more The vegetarian options were limited, but it didn’t really matter since the food itself was disappointing. I ordered a pasta dish with mushrooms and tomatoes, while my wife opted for chicken marsala. We received hefty portions, but the quality left much to be desired. We decided to skip dessert, and both of us experienced uncomfortable stomach aches afterward—I'll spare you the details. We won’t be returning. Additionally, the upstairs area, which was nice and spacious, has been closed off for some time, leaving only the cramped basement available for dining.

I came with my husband and we both ordered a salad and steak dish. Nothing spectacular, but the servings were HUGE. We felt that our salad was too heavily dress... read more I came with my husband and we both ordered a salad and steak dish. Nothing spectacular, but the servings were HUGE. We felt that our salad was too heavily dressed, but this was just a matter of personal preference. The cut of the steak was an okay cut, and the chef tried to cook it to the temp that we requested (medium rare and rare, but both were still overcooked).

Great service. Good menu. Love the basement bar. read more Great service. Good menu. Love the basement bar.