Casey's - Fargo

This is likely the worst Casey's in town. They offer specialty pizzas, but hardly any of the staff know how to make them. Management has struggled for over a year to order supplies properly. As for the pizza, the staff seems unable to distinguish between sauces, spreads, and toppings. They rarely have the pizza toppings on hand—no onions, everything's frozen, etc. On the bright side, the staff is at least friendly.

I ordered a pizza online for pickup at 6:08 PM and prepaid for it. When I arrived at 6:08, the staff member was chatting instead of making my pizza, which hadn't even been started, although my breadsticks were nearly ready. I had to leave and told them I would return. When I came back at 6:30, my pizza still wasn't started, and the employee informed me that they weren't making pizzas that night. I did get a refund, but I was very hungry and extremely disappointed. If I could give zero stars, I would. I won’t be returning to that Casey's again. Very incompetent service.

The employee at the checkout counter was fantastic. We filled up on gas and picked up some supplies at the convenience store. The pizza at Casey's is excellent, and there are plenty of other food items available too. Just keep in mind that grocery store items tend to be more expensive, which is typical for convenience stores.

I used to consider this one of the ?less nice? Casey?s in Fargo, and therefore spent very little time there. Just the occasional gas stop if desperate, like your average gas station run. More recently I went inside the store again, and I was surprised to see how nice it is. I?m not sure how new the inside is, but they clearly did some cleaning up and moving things around so that the store is much more pleasant now. And on a smaller note, though nothing will ever beat Happy Joe?s taco pizza (real ones know), Casey?s actually has a really decent replica! Their breakfast pizza is absolutely bomb as well.

Love Casey?s! Gas, air hose, and munchables in one quick stop. Their menu for pizza, sandwiches, sides, desserts, etc is a decent size. I order pizza with sides and desserts once a week, and they?ve never failed me. Casey?s rewards is also a really cool thing they got going on.