Otto's Fairplay

American, Cheese, Sandwiches
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Otto's Fairplay

Otto's Fairplay
4.7 / 5 (1903 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Otto's Fairplay from Fairplay featuring all 28 dishes and drinks can be found here on the list.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Liam

Images

Otto's Fairplay Food Otto's Fairplay Food Otto's Fairplay Inside Otto's Fairplay Outside

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 1903 reviews

Was Shawn Tolbert at Otto's Fairplay a mag?
Wonderful little joint to pick up amazing sandwiches. Inside seating is quant with just enough room. I had the Honey Hot Chicken. When I got it I was sceptical, but after the 1st bite I was blown away! Perfect crisp and the slaw on top wasn't overwhelming and added to the amazement of the sandwich. The Cajun fries were good, but not great. Maybe a little more seasoning would help. Drink choices are limited to cans bo... View all feedback.

What Pow Hound dislikes about Otto's Fairplay:
The prices are a bit high and the staff seems quite unengaged. The food is decent, but my experience was marred by the lack of interaction. During my visit on the morning of September 5th, the employee only spoke two words to me. I've spent my entire career in sales and customer service, so I know the importance of good service! View all feedback.

ethan-mestas
30.09.2024

I was pleasantly surprised by my visit to the South Park area, which I've only ever passed through briefly. However, Ottos has completely changed my opinion—it's definitely worth a visit, whether for takeout or dining in. I can confidently say that it's one of the best chicken sandwiches I've had in the state. My wife ordered the Cuban, and it was equally impressive.

kimberly-brewster-1
30.09.2024

A gluten-free fried chicken sandwich?! Absolutely yes!! This place is fantastic—definitely make sure to eat here!

pow-hound-2
30.09.2024

The prices are a bit high and the staff seems quite unengaged. The food is decent, but my experience was marred by the lack of interaction. During my visit on the morning of September 5th, the employee only spoke two words to me. I've spent my entire career in sales and customer service, so I know the importance of good service!

liam-dorton-1
30.09.2024

Parking lot isn't very large. Was fine for me on my motorcycle. Unfortunately, the road construction going on right now is out of their control, looking like it makes it a bit tighter than normal for those bigger vehicles. As for the food! They have a twist on a Cuban sandwich I've never had before, but it was most excellent! Made with what seemed to be real pulled pork and ham, not that processed stuff. Was definitely worth the stop! (Edit) I have returned since the first review and have not been disappointed. Gotta try the Cheesy Bacon Cow Girl Fries and the breakfast burrito

ryan-roberts-cactus6
30.09.2024

Food was definitely fresh! Employees were nice and welcoming and the time from order to table wasn't bad at all. Chicken was fried perfectly and the Cajun fries definitely had a good kick to them. My one and only complaint is with the seasoning of the chicken. It just needed something more, be it salt or a little kick.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.