Alfy's Pizza - Everett
Alfy's Pizza
Menu
The menu of Alfy's Pizza from Everett contains about 89 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $5.0 for a dish / drink.
Alfy's Pizza offers a mixed bag of experiences to its patrons. While some diners rave about their perfectly cooked crust and longstanding charm, others express deep disappointment, citing poor customer service and issues with food quality. Several customers reported instances of food poisoning and deceptive pricing practices, claiming advertised deals did not reflect the true cost. Despite these critiques, many nostalgic visitors fondly remember Alfy’s unique marinara sauce and appreciate the updated ambiance at the new location. With an expanded menu featuring milkshakes and donuts, there's potential for a revival, but significant consistency issues remain.
Reservation request for Alfy's Pizza
Feedback
Was Macie Flatley at Alfy's Pizza a mag?
Best crust and best cheese I've ever tried, even if compared to high-quality Italian restaurants that charge $35 for pizza that is smaller and soggy. Alfie's has never disappointed me in the 10 years that I go sporadic there View all feedback.
What Gabriel Gagné dislikes about Alfy's Pizza:
I had a disappointing experience with this restaurant. They canceled my order without any notification. When I called to inquire, they informed me that they were too busy filling a larger order. This suggests that they don't prioritize smaller customers, even though my order was worth over $100. The customer service is subpar, and I will never recommend this location to anyone. View all feedback.
I had a disappointing experience with this restaurant. They canceled my order without any notification. When I called to inquire, they informed me that they were too busy filling a larger order. This suggests that they don't prioritize smaller customers, even though my order was worth over $100. The customer service is subpar, and I will never recommend this location to anyone.
Great place for a variety of pizzas and other dishes. The best salad I've had for a long time! Very recommended!!
This Alfys location is terrible. The owner has just a sorry attitude as if put out by anyone being there, a real glass half empty type. I see I’m not the only one who has commented about this issue. I’ll be sure to share. Ruining the Alfys name where it was exciting and fun to be or grab a pizza that’s for sure. I suggest hiring more kind people to offset that “need a nap” attitude.
This place gave me food poisoning. The garlic sauce was curdled and being the only one in my family that ate the sauce and the only one sick im sure thats what it was. I ate nothing else yeaterday beaides your food and now this morning I am sick. I cant stop throwing up. Thanks. The pizza also had hardly any sauce and the crust was burnt but thats not as bad as food poisining. I wish I could get my 40$ back because throwing up with diarrhea is not worth the bad food. To bad because alfys used to be delicious. I will never be ordering from here again in my life and I advise others against it, for your own health and safety.
Menu
Soups, Sides And Salads , Breads
Build Your Own Salad To Gochoose your favorite items from our salad bar
$4.9
Mamas Chicken Strips5 strips of boneless white breast meat plus your choice of dipping sauce.
$6.8
One-Time-Through Salad Bar$4.9Pasta
Alfy's Classic Lasagnaauthentic italiana lasagna wih canadian bacon; sausage; mushrooms; mozzarella; & red sauce. served + garlic bread
$8.8P'zzandwich
Alfys Calzonealfys original crust; pizza sauce; cheese & choice of 3 fillings.
$5.9Drinks
20 Oz. Bottles Of Soda$1.7
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.2 / 5 (7140 reviews)Fast Food American BurgersRed Robin Gourmet Burgers
SE Everett Mall Way 1305, 98208-2817 Everett, US
"Decent food great milkshakes whiskey river burger is delicious"
★ 4.3 / 5 (4670 reviews)Asian Ice Cream Soup Chicken NoodlesTerracotta Red
Hewitt Avenue 2818, 98120 Everett, US
"Rice being a side is a bit of a bummer but overall really good."
★ 4.4 / 5 (11154 reviews)Seafood Steak Drinks Ice Cream CoffeeAnthony's Homeport
1726 W Marine View Dr Everett, WA 98201-2087, United States
"Our dinner was delicious and the service from Joshua was great!"