Reviews
What User doesn't like about Pauls Live From New York:
Honestly the best pizza I had in town BUT the lady who worked the register was the worst experience I ever had with restaurant staff. We had to say our order five times, but they interrupted and tried to do a whole readiness comedy routine. She wasn't funny and was terrible at her job to the point where we only go from now on to the Arcata location, so we never have to interact with her again. View all feedback. What User likes about Pauls Live From New York:
You'll immediately recognize how good this place is from the delightful aroma that fills the air. It far surpasses your typical pizza. We especially enjoyed the Sunset, which is a vegetarian Hawaiian pizza. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Not a little lie they ruined a pizza for me and my family, with how good the options were. I bought a total of five people food about what I think I bought seve...
read moreHonestly the best pizza I had in town BUT the lady who worked the register was the worst experience I ever had with restaurant staff. We had to say our order fi...
read moreI had the Hot stuff Pizza and garlic knots and my daughter had the cheese pizza, she was absolutely raving the whole time saying it was the best pizza she's eve...
read morePizza by the slice in Eureka! It's a no frills pizza joint. The pizza itself was really good. The pesto on it was great. Cashier was very pleasant.
The ordering was confusing. No one to help and girl counting out other register made no attempt to make eye contact and explain the situation. After about 5 min...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe spaghetti was good, and the salad along with the dressing was great. However, the side of dressing was quite small considering the size of the salad; an ext...
read moreI ordered my salad with blue cheese crumbles but received tomatoes instead. The lasagna was small and had very little meat. We love this restaurant, and I alway...
read moreIt could have easily been a 5-star review, but they forgot the condiments and utensils. They also missed including the marinara and the extra marina that I paid...
read moreDelicious salad. plenty of sauce
Tasty and hot plain wings.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThis place offers a great selection of pizza by the slice, and the slices are enormous! You order at the counter, and then they bring the pizza to your table. T...
read moreThe gluten-free pizza was excellent, and the regular pizza servings were enormous! One slice was about the size of my husband’s chest, which is quite amusing! W...
read moreAbsolutely fantastic pizza slices! New Amsterdam was amazing. The crust had a perfect chew, the sauce was delicious, the cheese was spot on, and the sausage was...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more