Evah's - Feedback

#18 - Pizza - Ely, American, Delivery Services

Reviews

Overall Total Score
3.4 out of 5
Good | 278 reviews

Was Bill V at Evah's a mag?
Eva's has now changed to Smash Burger! I'm not sure why the signs haven't been updated yet, but the burgers are excellent. I didn't see any Italian dishes on the menu, so it seems like the reviews might be outdated. View all feedback.

What Lynette F dislikes about Evah's:
If you are still open then you should still be serving food. Do t answer the phone just to let everyone know you can't help them. That is so stupid. You have a job to do. Do it. You guys are out in the middle of nowhere and weare all hungry. I am stranded here right now and I can't go anywhere. I haven't eaten a proper meal in a long time because I'm out in the middle of nowhere. You guys need to be more accommodatin... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Yelp

Last update : 05.11.2023

3.1 ★ from 43 reviews
anthony-g-flower966
05.11.2023

The Tomato Florentino soup of the day was exceptionally tasty and enjoyable. My wife absolutely loved the chicken parmesan salad and polished off every bite. I really savored my spaghetti with three meatballs; the marinara sauce was wonderful, the spaghetti was served warm, and the meatballs were incredible. I will definitely come back to this restaurant when I’m in Ely, NV.

lynette-f-tree446
05.11.2023

If you are still open then you should still be serving food. Do t answer the phone just to let everyone know you can't help them. That is so stupid. You have a job to do. Do it. You guys are out in the middle of nowhere and weare all hungry. I am stranded here right now and I can't go anywhere. I haven't eaten a proper meal in a long time because I'm out in the middle of nowhere. You guys need to be more accommodating to the travelers and realize more what they are going through and not be so selfish and just think of getting home. It's probably best if I starve anyways because I read the reviews and they were not very good and probably would give me food poisoning anyways.oh my goodness...I realized it says they are still open even now but won't serve anybody.gow stupid!

jennifer-h-forest4
05.11.2023

It's the only Italian place you'll find for a hundred miles... literally. Ordered the chicken parm and a dinner salad. Food was okay but over-priced. Service was super slow. Not sure if it was unusually busy for a Sunday night or if it's just normal. Be patient if you choose to eat here--bring a book or a board game. It's a bit of a wait.

robert-r-tree5089
05.11.2023

We ate here for dinner one night and they had obviously been busy prior to our arrival. There were two servers covering the whole restaurant. No host, or, bus boy. It took a while to be sat but they were friendly and helpful on helping us decide on food options. I ordered the spaghetti with a breaded chicken on top covered in cheese. Huge portion, it was 18 bucks or so. I did get two meals out of it. They brought us some bread to eat as well as my appetizer salad that was good. One person ordered a personal size pepperoni pizza which he was impartial to. The other meal was a pork bbq sandwich that was on special, it was ok, but nothing special. Probably left overs from a previous special. All in all it was a bit expensive for what we ordered, it wasn't our favorite location but not a bad place to eat if you are looking for Italian food.

makaela-c
05.11.2023

Amazing pasta! as other reviews have stated, the mac and cheese is great. i recommend the cheddar jalapeño poppers the lasagna bisque.

Located inside the Ramada hotel in Ely, this eatery offers a mix of Italian and American dishes, recently rebranded as Smash Burger with a new menu focus. While service is friendly and accommodating, it can be slow during busy times. Portions tend to be generous but prices are on the higher side. Some dishes like chicken parmesan salad and homemade soups receive praise, while others such as chicken strips disappoint. The atmosphere, especially upstairs overlooking hotel amenities, is pleasant. Overall, it’s a convenient, if somewhat pricey, option in a remote area with a welcoming staff and a changing menu.

Foursquare

Last update : 27.02.2025

1.5 ★ from 2 reviews
jess-johnson-library-2
27.02.2025

The restaurant has aunique atmosphere, but the food was quiteordinary.

jerry-miller-ivy04
05.11.2023

It's now a burger place!

Menu

Last update : 04.03.2023

5.0 ★ from 1 reviews
kuvalis-norberto
04.03.2023

The burgers were fantastic - handmade and very filling. Overall, it was a decent experience.

Menupix

Last update : 30.09.2024

3.8 ★ from 10 reviews
menupix-user-chef694
30.09.2024

The burgers were fantastic- handmade and generously portioned. Overall, everything was excellent.

Tripadvisor
3.5 ★ from 92 reviews
Restaurantguru
3.3 ★ from 130 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Ely