Murdick's Cafe - EDGARTOWN
Murdick's Cafe
Description
Murdick's Cafe in Martha's Vineyard offers a mix of experiences that leaves diners divided. While the café is often bustling and occasionally prone to service delays, many guests appreciate the rich, locally crafted fudge and delightful atmosphere. The coffee and fresh pastries receive praise for their quality, and the friendly staff help create a warm environment. However, some diners have expressed disappointment with slow service and occasional mix-ups with their orders. Despite these shortcomings, the café remains a charming stop for those eager to indulge in delicious fudge and satisfying sandwiches, making it worth a visit to experience its unique offerings.
Images
Feedback
It was quite busy, as expected. However, the coffee was excellent. If you're dining with a larger group, it's best to leave some members outside, as the space is a bit cramped.
Hands down the best Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on the island. Great service and quality food. Plus you can watch them make fudge while you wait for your food.
Google says 0530, website and menus say 0600, in actuality it's 0700 to open. Don't make early plans around them.
They make fudge right in front of the public. They had just made some peanut brittle and were giving samples. Very tasty. The lady that helped us was very nice.
I’ve eaten lunch here twice this month on day trips to the Vineyard, because I really like this cafe. The sandwich’s are large and filling with fresh ingredients, made by CherylAnn (I hope I have her name right). She’s a delight who always has a big engaging smile to share. And after lunch, fudge paradise awaits you in their heavenly chocolate shop 15 feet away through the doorway! Indulge and you’ll definitely enjoy. My fav is the Rocky Road chocolate fudge.
