Katama General Store - EDGARTOWN

#5 - Pizza - EDGARTOWN, American, Store

Katama General Store

Katama General Store
4.2 / 5 (455 reviews)

Description

Nestled on the route to South Beach, this transformed gem offers an impressive array of culinary delights. The shroom sandwich, featuring almond ricotta, and a delicious vegan pizza have garnered rave reviews, though some find the focaccia slightly oily. For those seeking heartier options, the lobster roll stands out—filled generously with succulent lobster on a soft brioche bun, it’s touted as one of the best in town. Additionally, the double patty smash burger captivates even the pickiest eaters, while customizable pizzas with fresh ingredients promise satisfaction. With a grab-and-go selection and enticing breakfast bowls, this spot is a must-visit.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: amandali1y

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 455 reviews
amandali1y
09.09.2024

I really enjoy the shroom sandwich for $13 with the option to substitute almond ricotta for an extra $1. They also offer a delicious vegan pizza and a beet wrap that I have yet to try. The focaccia bread can be a bit oily, so I recommend asking for it with light oil or substituting the bread altogether. The sandwich is served in a box, making it a bit difficult to eat on the go.

eleanora-eichmann
18.06.2023

I can still recall when this place on the route to South Beach was just a small hut. It has undergone a major transformation and now offers a variety of options from souvenirs and gifts to food, including sushi. However, the top reason to visit is their lobster roll, which is the most delicious dish I have ever had. Packed with plenty of lobster on a soft brioche bun, it is a steal at $32 (price subject to change).

darian-hayes
18.06.2023

We had the best burger and lobster roll at this restaurant on Martha's Vineyard. Even my toddler, who my wife worries is vegetarian, couldn't get enough of the burger. The double patty smash burger is cooked perfectly and the roasted potato bunk is delicious. The lobster roll is not complimentary, but they are generous with the meat and the bun is crispy and beautiful. Two family members claimed it was their favorite lobster roll ever, while one said it was their second favorite.

darian-hayes
18.06.2023

Karama General Store sells peaches at $12.99/lbs. Yeah, not cheap. That said they're delicious and worth it.

astrid-mclaughlin
18.06.2023

Just got the Mediterranean bowl for breakfast. I’m sure it’s one of the best I’ve had in quite some time. Pepper-y (and super fresh) greens, perfectly fried eggs, herbed yogurt and salsa — the perfect mix of all the things. I love a good bagel and schmear like most folks, but this was and super healthy!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.