Alchemy - EDGARTOWN

#23 - Pizza - EDGARTOWN, American, Vegetarian Friendly
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Alchemy

Alchemy
4.2 / 5 (2942 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Alchemy from EDGARTOWN includes 61 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $16.8. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Alchemy, a charming gem in Martha's Vineyard, offers an exceptional dining experience with a menu featuring fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and vibrant flavors. Guests rave about the rich and satisfying dishes, from crab salad to fish stew, while the attentive and friendly service enhances the overall ambiance. Despite a bustling summer crowd potentially impacting noise and service, the restaurant remains a go-to for romantic gatherings and special occasions. Diners appreciate the stunning architecture and cozy atmosphere, making it a memorable destination. Alchemy consistently delivers quality, ensuring it's worthy of repeat visits and heartfelt recommendations.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: OpenTable

Images

Alchemy Food Alchemy Food Alchemy Food Alchemy Food Alchemy Food

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 2942 reviews

Was Nella Howell at Alchemy a mag?
We visited Martha's Vineyard to celebrate our 18th wedding anniversary, and we were thoroughly impressed with Alchemy. The food was exceptional. I tried the fish stew, which was the evening's special, and it was delicious. The tempura green beans were amazing as well. They also had a fantastic wine selection. Overall, it was an A+ experience! View all feedback.

What Iancr dislikes about Alchemy:
Alchemy serves wonderful food with fresh local ingredients. The flavors were unusually intense and the food itself was rich and satisfying. Our experience has been over the years that this is a restaurant to visit in the off-season. In the middle of summer, the restaurant becomes noisy, the service more rushed and the food less delicious. View all feedback.

fmedhurst-library27
13.01.2023

Eating was extraordinary. varied menu. I had a Mexican stew that was delicious. the wine list was good. it was eating it over the top and great location.

nella82
13.01.2023

Alchemy offers an exceptional dining experience with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. The aromas were remarkably vibrant, and the dishes were rich and satisfying. Our experience suggests that this is a restaurant to visit in the upcoming season. During the height of summer, the restaurant tends to be noisy, the service can be rushed, and the food may not be as delightful.

corbin68
13.01.2023

Great place with a wonderful dining atmosphere. I just wish they offered some local beer options.

opentable-3
09.08.2023

Food was exceptional. Varied menu. I had a Mexican stew that was delicious. Wine list was good. It was the food that put it over the top and great location.

iancr
09.08.2023

Alchemy serves wonderful food with fresh local ingredients. The flavors were unusually intense and the food itself was rich and satisfying. Our experience has been over the years that this is a restaurant to visit in the off-season. In the middle of summer, the restaurant becomes noisy, the service more rushed and the food less delicious.

  • To Share

    Grey Barn Prufrock Cheese
    Grey Barn Prufrock Cheese
    $15.8
    Salt Pepper Crispy Clams
    Salt Pepper Crispy Clams
    $20.8
  • Entrées

    Jonah Crab Grilled Asparagus Salad
    Jonah Crab Grilled Asparagus Salad
    $17.8
    Corn Tortellini
    Corn Tortellini
    $17.8
    Seared Yellowfin Tuna Tartare*
    Seared Yellowfin Tuna Tartare*
    $20.8
  • Mains

    Alchemy's Wagyu Burger*
    Alchemy's Wagyu Burger*
    $25.7

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.