Pine Grove Inn - East Patchogue

The place was closed when I tried to go and was never notified read more The place was closed when I tried to go and was never notified

We ordered a few appetizers, but they arrived at staggered times, so we ended up eating at different intervals. Once we finished our appetizers, I found myself... read more We ordered a few appetizers, but they arrived at staggered times, so we ended up eating at different intervals. Once we finished our appetizers, I found myself having to clear the plates because nobody came to take them away. Although the waitress returned to take our drink orders, she left all the empty glasses on the table, forcing me to clear those away as well. When the main courses arrived, they were also served at different times. Some of our guests had already finished eating by the time the last dish finally arrived. Overall, this was the worst dining experience we've had, and we left very unhappy with the restaurant.

I started my meal with a glass of German Riesling from Bex, which was delightful and full of flavor. For dinner, I had the sour roast, served with potato pancak... read more I started my meal with a glass of German Riesling from Bex, which was delightful and full of flavor. For dinner, I had the sour roast, served with potato pancakes, red cabbage, and a touch of apple sauce. It was absolutely delicious, and I can't wait to go back! I’ve been telling everyone about how wonderful Pine Grove Inn is. The owner was friendly and welcoming, making the experience even more enjoyable.

Michael the bartender was amazing. Made us the best drinks and was so personable. Would definitely come back soon. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per... read more Michael the bartender was amazing. Made us the best drinks and was so personable. Would definitely come back soon. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

My girl and I went to Pine Grove for New Year’s Eve dinner. We were very happy with the service and the food. We had shrink scampi, and lobster mac cheese. Both... read more My girl and I went to Pine Grove for New Year’s Eve dinner. We were very happy with the service and the food. We had shrink scampi, and lobster mac cheese. Both were so good. The coffee was even delicious!