Agave - Dering Harbor

Very nice restaurant in Greenport. The inside is dark and not quite the waterfront vibe some people look for, but the food, drinks and service was very good and reasonably priced for the area. We had fish and shrimp tacos and sangria, all were very tasty.

The Quick: First time in, very impressed. Options for everyone and the chef accommodated our vegetarian/ vegan requests with grace. Lots of local fish options as well.

I give this restaurant only one star because the customer service was appalling. The food was good. But the taste of food could not overcompensate for the poor service we received from the waitress named Daisy. When I questioned Daisy about not getting our food after 40 minutes of waiting, her response was do you want your check. Instead her response should have been apologetic. The manager on duty instead did apologize and comp our drinks. But our experience had already been spoiled.

To start we've walked by this restaurant so many times and it's always busy and the food smells wonderful. Tonight we decided to try it and so pleased we did. We started off with drinks I had the blackberry frozen margarita... absolutely great. Next we had guacamole, salsa chips.... Great!!! The salsa had just the right amount of heat and guacamole was delicious. My daughter had the grilled shrimp tacos and my husband and I both had the shrimp scallop scampi.... It was really wonderful and not a dish you expect from a Mexican venue. No question Agave is now one of my absolute favorite restaurants now!!!!

Great cocktails, food and service at this Mexican restaurant on Front St. in Greenport. Many different 'Ritas to choose from. We went for the Cadillac and Top Shelf when we were advised that the jalapeños in the Jalapeño Pineapple Margarita were hot today. Really hot? we asked. Yes, hotter than usual. Hot! Great drinks, worth a bit of a wait. My husband enjoyed his Fish Tacos. I had the salmon served over a tomato, corn, squash and zucchini ragú with a pleasant, not overpowering tomato sauce. Salmon was cooked medium rare as requested. Nice atmosphere, tables close enough to others but not too close. Given seasonal destination, the pricing was very reasonable. We 'll be returning : .