Island Pie - Feedback

Vegan options are nice to see and the beet salad was good. More vegan options and some experimenting with different non-dairy cheeses would be even better. Food...

I had the pleasure of meeting the owners who were fantastic. We tried the Seasonal Squash and Sausage, as well as the Shallot Pizzas. They were both gluten-free...

This charming restaurant was a delightful find. When we arrived, we were lucky to be the only customers, allowing us to receive excellent service from the owner...

Delicious pizza and garlic sticks, plus very friendly and personable staff! We will absolutely be back next time we visit. After a day on the water, traveling,...

The staff at this restaurant was completely disorganized. They ignored me for 15 minutes and didn't even acknowledge my presence. I ended up leaving without bei...

Delicious vegetarian squash pizza with a unique, fresh and delicious cheesecake special dessert. the staff and owners are all friendly and helpful! the terrace...

After watching with a group of 8. the pizzas were good and the service was friendly. we have 4 pizzas and a few appetizers for all the table and it was enough....

We visited deer harbor for several days. we went first to island pie on Wednesday. it was very busy and the service showed that it was. no real coordination, ho...

This place is fantastic (I honestly don't understand the unfair low-ish 3.9 star rating it currently has). pizzas are so delicious: we have tried American with...

This place is amazing. The pizza was delicious! The lady that brought the pizza was super sweet. I imagine she was the owner as she knew a lot about the pizza,...

This restaurant is amazing (I truly don't understand the current low rating of 3.9 stars). The pizzas are incredibly delicious: we tried America's favorite with...

I had an incredible experience at this restaurant. The pizza was absolutely delicious! The woman who delivered the pizza was very kind. I believe she was the ow...

This restaurant is one of my top choices for dining out! The owners, a lovely and welcoming couple, have created a beautiful and inviting dining room atmosphere...

Pizza wa tasty we ordered the sausage pizza and the squash pizza. I have a milk allergy, so we asked for half cheese on both, it was no problem for them. We als...

We met the owner and she's very nice. The food and wine tastes great. Definitely coming back for more authentic Italian cuisine. The freshly baked Focaccia was...

Foodies rejoice! Island Pie offers a mouthwatering array of tasty pizza, stromboli, wine, desserts, and more to tantalize your taste buds. Their pasta dishes ar...

I had a great time at this restaurant yesterday. The staff was extremely friendly, especially our server Skye, who was enjoyable to talk to about her ambitions...