Island Pie - Deer Harbor

This is one of my favorite places to eat! The owners are a wonderfully kind couple that provide a beautiful and welcoming dining atmosphere. My husband and I have made multiple day trips from the Seattle area specifically to visit, where we can watch the boats in the marina over a glass of wine and delicious pizza. Highly recommend the seasonal squash offering the fall, that one was gone almost the second it hit the table!

If you have to choose between this pizza and bagel bites choose the bagle bites. Worst pizza ever. Crust was super hard and yucky.

The pizza felt like frozen pizza. The crust was super hard and chewy. The pesto white pizza was very overpowering and just tasted salty. I am a pesto lover and didn’t like this pizza at all. Very sad because we were excited to try this place while staying in Deer Harbor

We called Island Pie a few times to see if we could make reservations, or place an order to go. They never answered their phone and we couldn’t find anywhere on their website or Yelp to make reservations or place an order to go. After looking at their website and all the choices we had to choose from, we decided to drive a long distance to Island Pie. When we arrived, there was only outdoor seating and there may have been three or four tables with customers. We stood at the front and greeted by a young woman who advised us they were not serving people any longer; it was probably 6:45 in the evening. We asked if we could order something to go and she said yes and advised us to look at the menu that was taped to the front window. Unbeknownst to us, their menu is not the same menu on their website, it’s probably a third of the choices. In the meantime, as we we were trying to figure out what we wanted because what we originally wanted was no longer on the in-person menu, other people came up and got in line to place an order. When we got in line to place the order, the same woman said, well you took so long, it’s now going to take two hours to get any to-go order. We left and felt disrespected and not appreciated by the waitress. She was snotty and unprofessional. We are business owners ourselves and our employees would never treat a prospective client, customer, patron so unkindly. When you read other 1-star reviews, you see how defensive Island pie’s responses are. We will not be returning to Island pie.

BEST PIZZA,BEST LOCATION, this place is a MUST GO at orcas Island. Our server Sibu was AMAZING!! Parking: Great Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: The Sausage, White Pizza Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot