Backyard Grille - Custer

#5 - Fast Food - Custer, #10 - Pizza - Custer, Grill
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Backyard Grille

Backyard Grille
4.5 / 5 (118 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 8 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu of Backyard Grille from Custer.

This restaurant offers a tantalizing array of dishes that impress, with standout items like broasted pork chops and delectable reubens earning high praise from customers. However, service inconsistencies mar the experience, with reports of inattentive staff and unclear billing leading to frustration. While some patrons enjoyed their meals and delightful drinks, others faced rude service and long waits for basic needs. Pricing issues also emerged, raising questions about value for money. Ultimately, while the food shines through, the overall dining experience can vary dramatically, leaving potential diners to temper expectations regarding service.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: David

Images

Backyard Grille Food Backyard Grille Food Backyard Grille Logo Backyard Grille Food Backyard Grille Food Backyard Grille Food Backyard Grille Logo Backyard Grille Food

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 118 reviews

Was Dorcas Schowalter at Backyard Grille a mag?
This place has excellent food. I am very particular about my reubens, but this place deserves a perfect score of 10/10. I have savored every bite and the service was great with no complaints. View all feedback.

What Aiyana Stiedemann dislikes about Backyard Grille:
Food was ok. Service sucked. First waitress was nice. The lady who brought our food out was a bit stand off ish. Never asked if we needed anything. During the entire meal no one came by our table and asked how it was or inquired if we needed another drink. Had to ask for our bill. Too busy at the end of the bar with her friends drinking. Normally we tip very well, over 20%, this didn't even deserve the $2 tip I left.... View all feedback.

ahauck-2
16.07.2022

"Fantastic fish fry with delicious cakes, catfish, and bluegill. The portions are generous, the cuts are made by hand, and the drinks are outstanding!"

dorcas-schowalter
16.07.2022

This place has excellent food. I am very particular about my reubens, but this place deserves a perfect score of 10/10. I have savored every bite and the service was great with no complaints.

alberta-wiegand
16.07.2022

I highly recommend this place - the best burger I have ever had! The staff and service are fantastic. I will definitely be returning!

david-ahles-1
19.09.2024

This is a fantastic spot to enjoy a meal and a couple of drinks.

andy-thompson-4
19.09.2024

While I was out working, I stumbled upon this restaurant for lunch and was pleasantly surprised by the delicious food. It's a great spot to grab a bite and relax for a bit. I will definitely be coming back when I'm in the area again.

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.